Roma's goal machine sputters in Champions League debut after seven years away

Roma have scored ten goals and conceded just one in their opening matches of the 2026-27 season, establishing themselves as one of Europe's most potent attacking forces. The Giallorossi drew with Fenerbahce in their Champions League debut, a match in which Dybala and his teammates performed creditably in a hostile atmosphere. Gasperini now prepares Roma for Monday's fixture against Torino, expecting the same intensity shown in the early league games. The underlying statistics are remarkable: across three matches, Roma have recorded 71 shots while allowing only 22, a +49 differential that ranks second in Europe's five major leagues. Only Barcelona surpass them with a +58 difference. Barcelona also lead Roma on goals scored, 12 to 10, but the squads are incomparable—a gap illustrated when Barcelona defeated Feyenoord 5-1 in their own Champions League opener. Gasperini is pursuing a fourth consecutive victory, a streak Roma have not achieved since 2014.

Roma drew 0–0 at Fenerbahce in the Champions League group phase on 11 September, but the match exposed tactical vulnerabilities in Gasperini's system for the first time this season. The away side created only 0.48 expected goals—a figure not seen since March against Como and Genoa—as the Turkish side's fluid movement and refusal to adopt rigid positional play opened gaps in Roma's defence. Greenwood was a particular problem, threatening both in the first half and when he set up Brown's disallowed goal, finding space through Roma's compressed lines. Gasperini's high-risk, man-to-man defensive approach has powered Roma through their opening three Serie A matches, but it carries inherent dangers: when opponents move freely without fixed positions rather than following set structures, the system can unravel. The article identifies PSG—whose system under Luis Enrique is specifically designed to dismantle pressing defences—and similarly fluid sides like Inter and Como as potential threats going forward. Mancini's individual error contributed to Fenerbahce's threat, but the structural problem goes deeper: Roma's defensive and midfield lines were repeatedly caught out of shape by Fenerbahce's movement patterns. Yet the article argues Gasperini can take pride in Roma's overall performance. The team dominated Fenerbahce's pitch and showed the confidence and control that define top sides, returning to the Champions League for the first time in seven years without appearing overawed. The article emphasises that Roma "can now play with anyone" and possesses a genuine squad capable of sustaining a title challenge if Gasperini can tighten these defensive weaknesses. That balance—establishing a competitive edge against elite opposition whilst minimising the tactical flaws inherent in the manager's philosophy—will define Roma's season.

Roma's largely competent European debut in Istanbul revealed defensive weaknesses that Gasperini has identified as a pressing concern. The head coach used the term "vulnerability" to describe moments when the team struggled, pointing to systemic issues rather than the quality of opposition alone. Goals conceded early in the second half against both Atalanta and Fenerbahçe have prompted Gasperini to look inward at Roma's own mechanisms, rather than dismiss the lapses as coincidence. Gasperini has pinpointed defensive organisation as the area requiring immediate attention. The current Roma side plays with a notably higher defensive line and different structure than last season, operating in a distinctly Gasperini mould with increased possession and emphasis on vertical passes. However, that tactical approach comes with exposure that must be corrected before it hardens into a lasting weakness. The coach's intervention signals he views this as a technical rather than mental problem, requiring tactical adjustment or restoration of previous patterns. In his post-match analysis, Gasperini framed the recurring pattern as indicative of a deeper issue, stating: "We make more errors when we are set up a certain way. There are moments in the match when we are more vulnerable." Reflecting on the goal conceded by Brown, he explained: "We came out poorly but that happens when we are deep compared to when we play in their half of the pitch. We repeated it on other occasions." The message is clear: Roma must tighten defensive mechanics to build on an encouraging but imperfect opening.

Roma's opening week in the Champions League has delivered both significant encouragement and a small warning signal. The club's comeback victory against Atalanta—from 1–0 down to a 2–1 win in four minutes—and a draw away to Fenerbahce have created a picture of a squad with considerable depth and psychological resilience, but also a pattern worth monitoring in the matches ahead. Bryan Cristante emerged as the week's standout performer and the clearest evidence of Roma's evolution under Gasperini. Against Fenerbahce, Cristante scored the opening goal and touched the ball 112 times, completing 91 passes and playing 24 balls into the final third. His rise from useful squad member to gravitational centre of the team's balance, personality and order has become impossible to ignore. The bench itself proved the most interesting development of the week. When Gasperini made changes against Atalanta, the team did not lose force but gained it. Nahuel Molina increased the team's thrust down the flank, Santiago Castro signalled he is ready to make an impact, and Matías Soulé came off the bench to decide the match. Leonardo Balerdi also impressed, intent on climbing the manager's hierarchy. Roma's refusal to accept defeat completed the narrative: at 89 minutes against Atalanta, trailing 1–0, the side won 2–1 in the next four minutes through Mario Hermoso and Soulé. That capacity to keep playing and pushing until the final second is among the week's best signals. Two consecutive early-second-half goals, however, have begun to form a pattern. Ederson scored at 47 minutes in Roma's win over Atalanta; Brown equalised at 48 minutes in Fenerbahce's match against Roma. Gasperini himself acknowledged after Istanbul: "they are two clues." It does not necessarily signal a structural problem, but Roma has taken a few minutes too long to fully switch back on after the interval in both games. Donyell Malen's dip comes not from genuine crisis but from unrealistic expectations. He began the season in exaggerated form—multiple goals, a barrage of them, and the sense that every touch would create a chance. Two scoreless matches were enough to shift perception, though he supplied an assist for Cristante against Fenerbahce. At Istanbul he appeared less brilliant and dominant than in his opening displays. Gianluca Mancini and Wesley, meanwhile, remain undisputed pillars but have not yet shown their best form. Mancini has appeared less dominant and assured than his standard, while Wesley must rediscover the continuity, brilliance and ability to devastate the flank that had made him among Roma's most incisive players. No alarm: simply two important engines not yet running at full revs.

Radio pundits dissected Roma's recent performances in commentary collected by Romanews.eu, with particular focus on individual players and the squad's depth in key areas. Carina highlighted criticism of Roma as excessive, noting that in 30 years of broadcasting he had rarely been unable to speak with colleagues—disrupted by an unusually long pre-match show of an hour and a half before kickoff and 30 minutes after. He praised Roma's first-half display as dominant, saying from the stadium he had the sense Roma would not lose and could even win. However, he identified a pattern of defensive lapses: "Mancini has made errors in three matches: Lecce, Atalanta and Fenerbahce. There are some interpreters who at the moment are not doing well—for example, Mancini and Wesley." He noted Atalanta and Fenerbahce have both played with tight lines to double-mark Malen, a problem requiring tactical adjustment. Carina expected three changes for Monday's fixture, anticipating Balerdi might play and raising doubt about whether Koné would be risked after requesting a change mid-match. He observed Roma is short in midfield: "Koné came out and Pisilli came in, but he is a midfielder. De Roon is the substitute for Cristante. To me something is missing there." Pruzzo took a more critical view of squad quality, stating: "I have many doubts about the fact that the squad is qualitatively strong as one hears said—I don't have this perception." He praised Roma's first-half football but saw a dip in the second half when tactical changes were required. Pruzzo identified Castro as Roma's best option from the bench and believed the forward needed to unlock his potential. "The next one could be the right occasion," Pruzzo said. "It is inevitable that Castro has the need to score." He questioned other signings, noting Molina replicates Rensch's role and Mora contributed little in the most recent match.

Roma travel to Turin on Monday to face Torino, with encouraging news from the medical department. Manu Koné, who left the Istanbul match with knee discomfort, did not require scans and will be managed day by day; his inclusion in the squad for Monday is very likely, though he is expected to start on the bench. With Torino followed by an Inter fixture just five days later, Gasperini is preparing to rotate more heavily across the squad. Wesley, not yet fully recovered from ankle problems, could give way to Rensch or Molina, who is seeking his first start. The defence faces changes too: Mancini is struggling for form and faces competition from Balerdi, who has impressed in recent outings, and Ghilardi. Up front, Santiago Castro is pushing for a starting role, but a rotation with Malen appears more likely at present. Cristante is the only guaranteed starter in midfield, with Pisilli or De Roon potential partners alongside him. There is also positive news on the horizon: Lorenzo Pellegrini could return to the squad list, giving the coach more tactical options.

Gian Piero Gasperini is preparing to rotate his squad heavily ahead of matches against Torino and Inter, with Koné, Dybala, Malen and Mancini among those likely to be rested. Castro, Mora, Soulé, Pisilli and De Roon are expected to see more action as Roma look to preserve their key players and test the depth of the squad while addressing defensive issues that have emerged in recent fixtures. Salah-Eddine's departure to Panathinaikos is confirmed. The left-back moves on a loan deal with a right of redemption and underwent medical tests in Athens today to complete the transfer. Separately, defender Oosterwolde has reopened the possibility of joining Roma. An achilles tendon operation had scuppered a move earlier this summer, but Oosterwolde met with Roma officials in Istanbul and signalled his willingness to return. "I hope to come back to Roma in the coming months," he said. The club remains interested with D'Amico continuing to monitor developments. Gasperini values Oosterwolde's versatility, and his recovery from surgery will be key to determining whether Roma can revive the deal as early as January. Carina told Radio Radio: "I've read plenty of criticism of Roma. In 30 years doing this job I'd never known a situation where I couldn't speak to my colleague—there was an absurd broadcast an hour and a half before the match and 30 minutes after. Given where it was played, Roma put in a more than decent performance: they dominated the first half. From the stadium, I had the sense that Roma wouldn't lose it, and could even have won it." Pruzzo added: "I saw a good Roma. What I keep thinking is that I have many doubts about whether the squad is qualitatively as strong as people say: I don't have that perception. In the first half they played like last season, but in the second, when you need to change, there isn't the same level. I think Castro is Roma's best option off the bench. Then Molina comes on and does the same thing as Rensch, and Mora yesterday did nothing."

Roma drew their first match of the season, a result that has handed fuel to the club's most vocal critics. A goal by Brown was enough to stir the naysayers from silence after Roma's bright start to the campaign. The criticism ranges widely: that Roma have faced no genuine test in the league; that Malen has misfired; that Mora is merely a former Porto substitute out of his depth; that Gasperini has grown quiet where he once railed against "Ricky"; that Mancini is finished; that Wesley's focus lies elsewhere; that Koné avoids celebrating goals with teammates for unexplained reasons; that Gasperini's substitutions were wrong; that when he withdrew Malen he brought on De Roon out of friendship rather than judgment, a claim absurd coming from those who called Castro an inexplicable signing in the first place; and that Rensch played only as a favour, a serious tactical error. The draw in Istanbul itself has become a flashpoint for those determined to cast shadows over both Roma and their manager. Critics claim it proves Roma have not faced quality opposition in domestic play. The broader narrative from the pessimists is one of decline and poor judgment—both in the squad assembled and in how it is being used. Yet the tone of the piece suggests the critics are opportunistic, seizing on a single result to resurrect doubts that the strong start had quieted. The article offers no quarter to this chorus of doom, treating their complaints with contempt as a predictable cycle: the naysayers announced player exits before 30 June; they questioned the signings of Castro and Balerdi; and now, having seen their early predictions of collapse proven wrong by the opening fixtures, they are back in full voice. The sense is one of inevitable, tiresome repetition—the "Brancaleone Army" undeterred and unrelenting in its determination to find failure.

Radio pundits dissected Roma's recent performances in commentary collected by Romanews.eu, with particular focus on individual players and the squad's depth in key areas. Carina highlighted criticism of Roma as excessive, noting that in 30 years of broadcasting he had rarely been unable to speak with colleagues—disrupted by an unusually long pre-match show of an hour and a half before kickoff and 30 minutes after. He praised Roma's first-half display as dominant, saying from the stadium he had the sense Roma would not lose and could even win. However, he identified a pattern of defensive lapses: "Mancini has made errors in three matches: Lecce, Atalanta and Fenerbahce. There are some interpreters who at the moment are not doing well—for example, Mancini and Wesley." He noted Atalanta and Fenerbahce have both played with tight lines to double-mark Malen, a problem requiring tactical adjustment. Carina expected three changes for Monday's fixture, anticipating Balerdi might play and raising doubt about whether Koné would be risked after requesting a change mid-match. He observed Roma is short in midfield: "Koné came out and Pisilli came in, but he is a midfielder. De Roon is the substitute for Cristante. To me something is missing there." Pruzzo took a more critical view of squad quality, stating: "I have many doubts about the fact that the squad is qualitatively strong as one hears said—I don't have this perception." He praised Roma's first-half football but saw a dip in the second half when tactical changes were required. Pruzzo identified Castro as Roma's best option from the bench and believed the forward needed to unlock his potential. "The next one could be the right occasion," Pruzzo said. "It is inevitable that Castro has the need to score." He questioned other signings, noting Molina replicates Rensch's role and Mora contributed little in the most recent match.

Gian Piero Gasperini is preparing to rotate his squad heavily ahead of matches against Torino and Inter, with Koné, Dybala, Malen and Mancini among those likely to be rested. Castro, Mora, Soulé, Pisilli and De Roon are expected to see more action as Roma look to preserve their key players and test the depth of the squad while addressing defensive issues that have emerged in recent fixtures. Salah-Eddine's departure to Panathinaikos is confirmed. The left-back moves on a loan deal with a right of redemption and underwent medical tests in Athens today to complete the transfer. Separately, defender Oosterwolde has reopened the possibility of joining Roma. An achilles tendon operation had scuppered a move earlier this summer, but Oosterwolde met with Roma officials in Istanbul and signalled his willingness to return. "I hope to come back to Roma in the coming months," he said. The club remains interested with D'Amico continuing to monitor developments. Gasperini values Oosterwolde's versatility, and his recovery from surgery will be key to determining whether Roma can revive the deal as early as January. Carina told Radio Radio: "I've read plenty of criticism of Roma. In 30 years doing this job I'd never known a situation where I couldn't speak to my colleague—there was an absurd broadcast an hour and a half before the match and 30 minutes after. Given where it was played, Roma put in a more than decent performance: they dominated the first half. From the stadium, I had the sense that Roma wouldn't lose it, and could even have won it." Pruzzo added: "I saw a good Roma. What I keep thinking is that I have many doubts about whether the squad is qualitatively as strong as people say: I don't have that perception. In the first half they played like last season, but in the second, when you need to change, there isn't the same level. I think Castro is Roma's best option off the bench. Then Molina comes on and does the same thing as Rensch, and Mora yesterday did nothing."

Gasperini is preparing to rotate his Roma squad for the Torino match while maintaining the quality displayed in the opening three Serie A fixtures. The coach said months after his arrival: "I need everyone." That statement has become urgent now that Roma have returned to the Champions League after seven years, making a packed fixture list impossible to navigate with the same eleven players throughout. Gasperini, not naturally inclined toward rotation, will make targeted changes across defence and attack—adjustments studied carefully rather than wholesale alterations. The forward line will see the most significant shifts. Paulo Dybala, who has started every match so far and remains injury-free, will be protected by dropping him from the starting eleven to preserve his fitness over the long season. Rodrigo Mora is ready to replace him and operate alongside Matías Soulé in support roles. The key decision surrounds the central striker position: Gasperini must choose between Santiago Castro, the Argentine keen to prove himself beyond a reserve role—he scored the decisive goal against Torino last season when he was at Bologna—and Donyell Malen, who has scored four goals in three matches and shows no sign of slowing down. Gasperini may start Malen again to try to settle the match early. The decision will be confirmed in the coming 48 hours. Roma possess sufficient alternatives to rotate without sacrificing quality, marking a rare shift in Gasperini's approach to squad management this season.

Donyell Malen has scored five goals in Roma's first three league matches and will look to extend his advantage over other strikers when Roma travel to Turin on Monday. The forward finished second in last season's goalscoring chart behind Lautaro Martinez despite arriving in January, and is aiming for the top spot in his second campaign in Italian football. Ciro Immobile, the former Lazio striker and four-time league top scorer, backed Malen's bid. Speaking to Fantacalcio.it, Immobile said: "Probably it will be him who wins. The start is like that of a top scorer." Malen, now in his second season in Serie A, is hunting for his first capocannoniere title.