Referee analysis: Rensch goal valid, Roma penalty justified, but questions over Mancini incident
Match Report·11 May 2026·56d ago

Referee analysis: Rensch goal valid, Roma penalty justified, but questions over Mancini incident

Source: Forza Roma

Referee Gianpaolo Calvarese has analysed a contentious match between Roma and Parma, offering his verdict on several disputed moments. In the first half, Roma appealed for two penalties: the first came when Circati made contact with Dybala's arm, but Calvarese assessed that the defender's objective was to create space for the ball rather than obstruct play, making it non-punishable. The second involved Valenti's challenge on Mancini from a falling ball; while contact occurred, the VAR did not intervene because the defender simultaneously cleared the ball.

In the second half, the annulment of Pellegrino's goal drew heavy criticism after Troilo's movement interfered with Svilar's dive. A silent VAR check examined whether Mancini's arm made contact as Rensch scored the 2–2, but Calvarese determined the impact was with the defender's flank and would not have been punishable regardless. The final flashpoint was the penalty awarded to Roma following an on-field review: Rensch gained an advantage over Britschgi through body-to-body contact as he moved into position ahead of his opponent, which constituted a foul.

Calvarese's analysis provides context for the match's volatile nature and the VAR's intervention points throughout.

● AI Generated Summary

This summary was generated by an AI model. Always read the source for complete and accurate information.

Testo Originale / Source Text

Calvarese: “Rensch è avanti, giusto il rigore. Dubbi su Mancini” - Forzaroma.info Forzaroma.infoI migliori video scelti dal nostro canaleforzaroma rassegna stampa il tempo Calvarese: “Rensch è avanti, giusto il rigore. Dubbi su Mancini”Il TempoCalvarese: “Rensch è avanti, giusto il rigore. Dubbi su…

Read the full article in Italian at Forza Roma.

Read original on Forza Roma

More Match Report

Roma confirm friendly against Newport County in August
Club NewsMatch Report AI
21h ago

Roma confirm friendly against Newport County in August

AS Roma have officially confirmed a pre-season friendly against Newport County on 4 August at Rodney Parade stadium in Wales, with kickoff at 19:00 local time (20:00 Italy time). The match is managed by former Leicester manager Fuchs and represents Roma's second test in the United Kingdom during their summer schedule. Information for visiting supporters' tickets will be communicated in the coming days. The Newport County fixture slots into Roma's busy pre-season calendar as they prepare for the Serie A season opener against Fiorentina. The friendly comes after an earlier match against Cardiff on 1 August, followed by another game at Brighton on 8 August. After these English fixtures, Roma will face Borussia Dortmund on 15 August in their final warm-up before domestic competition resumes. These matches form part of the club's preparations under their summer training camp, with player fitness and tactical development a priority ahead of the new season.

Koné impresses France, makes case to forget injured Tchouameni
Match ReportAnalysis AI
1d ago

Koné impresses France, makes case to forget injured Tchouameni

Roma midfielder Manu Koné started for France in their Round of 16 World Cup match against Paraguay, replacing the injured Aurélien Tchouameni. Despite the absence of Real Madrid's midfielder, French media and supporters have praised Koné's solid display. France won 1–0 thanks to a Kylian Mbappé penalty, advancing to the quarter-finals while demonstrating resilience against a compact defensive opponent. Koné earned widespread acclaim for his performance across both defensive and attacking phases. Journalist Olivier Bossard of L'Équipe stated: "I am not concerned about Tchouameni's absence. I think Koné will be very good and hold firm. We are not losing quality—in fact, we may even improve with him, because we gain attacking options without losing anything in defence." The Roma midfielder recorded 88 touches, tied for the match high, and attempted three long-range shots while making continuous defensive interventions. RMC Sport named him man of the match, though some outlets such as Le Figaro highlighted technical errors in the first half. Deschamps' assistant Guy Stéphan described Koné as "a different type of player, one with quality and a different profile," emphasizing his ball recovery abilities and distribution. Koné was cautioned late in the match but demonstrated the work rate and versatility that satisfied French staff and supporters alike.

France edge past Paraguay in World Cup quarter-final; Koné reflects on physical contest
Match Report AI
1d ago

France edge past Paraguay in World Cup quarter-final; Koné reflects on physical contest

France advanced to the World Cup quarter-finals with a narrow 1–0 victory over Paraguay, secured by a penalty converted by Kylian Mbappé. The South American side proved a tough and physical opponent, but France maintained composure and achieved their objective. Midfielder Manu Koné was among those praised for his performance in a demanding match. Koné, who currently plays for AS Roma, delivered a composed display in midfield against Paraguay's aggressive approach. He spoke about the nature of the contest after the match, noting the physicality on display and the tactical awareness required to navigate it without being drawn into unnecessary confrontation. The midfielder highlighted France's preparation and intelligence in handling the situation. In his post-match comments to beIN Sports, Koné reflected: "It was a very hard match, but we are happy. Today we adapted. They were a rather... physical team! We choose our words carefully (smiles). We managed to stand up to our opponents in the challenges, we won 1–0, we were effective. There were some excessive interventions, but we didn't fall into their trap. The coach had warned us during the week. We were intelligent, we just wanted to win." France's disciplined approach proved decisive in securing progression to the next stage.

More on Paulo Dybala

Player profile →
Celik advances on contract renewal; Dybala signature expected soon; Roma confirms another friendly
Transfer NewsClub News AI
18h ago

Celik advances on contract renewal; Dybala signature expected soon; Roma confirms another friendly

AS Roma is making progress on a contract renewal for Celik, while Paulo Dybala is expected to sign a new deal soon. The club has also officially confirmed another friendly match as part of pre-season preparations. Details on the specific terms and timeline for these developments remain unclear, though the renewal talks appear to be moving forward positively.

Paredes on Dybala's potential Boca move: wishes him well regardless
Transfer NewsOpinion AI
1d ago

Paredes on Dybala's potential Boca move: wishes him well regardless

Leandro Paredes, the former Roma midfielder, was interviewed by DAZN while competing for Argentina in a World Cup campaign. The interview touched on Paulo Dybala and speculation surrounding a possible move to Boca Juniors. Paredes expressed goodwill toward his former Roma teammate, indicating that regardless of whether Dybala joins Boca, he wishes him the best. Dybala remains a key figure in Roma's current squad. The comments reflect the broader context of player movements during international breaks, though specifics of any transfer discussion remain unclear.

Roma to launch Greenwood bid by Tuesday; Dovbyk-Genoa move gains traction
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
1d ago

Roma to launch Greenwood bid by Tuesday; Dovbyk-Genoa move gains traction

AS Roma is preparing to submit an official offer for English winger Mason Greenwood to Olympique Marseille in the coming days, with the bid expected around Tuesday. The package is reported to be worth approximately €45 million including bonuses, with Roma aiming to move ahead of rival interest from Atlético Madrid. In parallel, Argentine striker Artem Dovbyk is being pursued by Genoa, where former Roma manager Daniele De Rossi now coaches. Roma has shown openness to a loan arrangement for Dovbyk, though his wage demands remain a significant hurdle to any deal materializing. Meanwhile, Roma is also scouting attacking depth. For the role of deputy to Donyell Malen, the club is considering Nicolò Tresoldi from Club Bruges and Andrea Pinamonti from Sassuolo, with Lazio also keen on Pinamonti. Separately, midfielder Leandro Paredes has spoken publicly about Paulo Dybala's future. Paredes said: "For me it would be a pleasure to have him with me at Boca, then he will make his own decisions and surely will have many things on his mind." Dybala's contract status and potential departure remain topics of speculation as the transfer window enters a critical phase.

More on Gianluca Mancini

Player profile →
Celik Close to Contract Extension but Not Gasperini's First Choice at Right-back
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
6d ago

Celik Close to Contract Extension but Not Gasperini's First Choice at Right-back

Zeki Celik is close to signing a new three-year contract with AS Roma following Turkey's elimination from the World Cup at the group stage. The club and player have reached an agreement in principle, with an announcement expected in the coming days. However, Celik will not be Gasperini's starting right-back. The head coach has requested reinforcement on the right flank and views Celik as a versatile option who can operate on either wing or as a right centre-back to rotate with Gianluca Mancini. Gasperini's primary target for the right-back position is a younger profile than Molina, who is considered a secondary option at 28 years old. Dodô is not being pursued, as Roma has not made any formal approach for the player. On the left side, Wesley remains a key part of the plans after rejecting Chelsea and is ready for the upcoming season. Ruggeri is not a target for Roma. The club will seek an alternative to Wesley on the left, with Angeliño expected to depart. Roma continues to work on contract extensions for key players, with Celik's renewal progressing alongside talks with Paulo Dybala and Lorenzo Pellegrini regarding their own deals.

Inter renews interest in Roma's Ndicka and Pisilli as alternatives to other targets
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
7d ago

Inter renews interest in Roma's Ndicka and Pisilli as alternatives to other targets

Inter has reportedly reactivated contact with AS Roma defender Evan Ndicka as the Serie A transfer window officially opens. The club is exploring alternatives after failing to secure other defensive targets. Ndicka, currently on international duty with Ivory Coast, is considered a key reinforcement for Inter's defence, but Roma head coach Gian Piero Gasperini views him as non-transferable. Inter's pursuit of other defensive options, including an unnamed player reportedly from another club, has stalled, prompting the renewed approach for the Roma defender. Niccolò Pisilli has also emerged as a potential target for Inter, with reports suggesting the club is considering the Roma midfielder as an alternative in their search for a successor in that position. The 2004-born midfielder is valued at approximately 25 million euros. However, both Ndicka and Pisilli have repeatedly expressed their commitment to Roma, and the club has made clear it does not wish to part with either player. Gasperini's stance on keeping these players is firm, presenting significant obstacles to any Inter move. Closing a 30-million-euro deal or higher in the remaining hours before the deadline would prove extremely difficult logistically. Additionally, Gianluca Mancini is approaching a contract extension with Roma and is unlikely to move to Milan.

Oliveira returns to Roma for El Shaarawy's wedding, reunites with former Conference League teammates
Club News AI
7d ago

Oliveira returns to Roma for El Shaarawy's wedding, reunites with former Conference League teammates

Sergio Oliveira, the Portuguese midfielder who left Roma, returned to the city to attend the wedding of El Shaarawy and Ludovica Pagani. At the celebration, Oliveira reconnected with former teammates Lorenzo Pellegrini, Bryan Cristante, and Gianluca Mancini—players with whom he won the UEFA Europa Conference League in 2022. Oliveira shared his reflections on social media about his time at Roma, saying: "Roma is special. It has brought me so much. Not only sporting moments but mainly fantastic people. I am very happy to be here on this beautiful day, a truly special moment for my friend Ste. Even though we spent little time together, when you share the same values it becomes easy to understand each other and lend a hand. Thank you to you all and I wish you a life full of happiness." The post underscores the bond formed during the Giallorossi's successful European campaign and the lasting relationships built within the club. The wedding also included attendance from other Roma-connected figures, with details of their presence marking another chapter in the club's recent history of trophy success.

More on Mile Svilar

Player profile →
Juventus Target Premier League Goalkeeper After Roma Reject €42 Million Bid for Svilar
Transfer NewsClub News AI
1d ago

Juventus Target Premier League Goalkeeper After Roma Reject €42 Million Bid for Svilar

Juventus have begun their search for a new goalkeeper after deciding to part ways with Michele Di Gregorio, who underperformed last season and lost his starting position to Mattia Perin. The club's first choice was AS Roma's Mile Svilar, but Roma rejected a substantial €42 million offer. Gian Piero Gasperini has no intention of selling his starting keeper, particularly as Roma prepare for their first Champions League appearance in nearly a decade. With Svilar unavailable, Juventus have shifted focus to Aston Villa's Emiliano Martinez. Martinez has impressed both for Argentina on World Cup duty and for Villa, where he helped secure a Europa League trophy and a top-four Premier League finish. However, his contract at Villa Park runs until 2029, and the club has set a €15 million price tag on the Argentine goalkeeper. Juventus have already deemed Villa's valuation excessive, considering Martinez will turn 34 in September. Despite his age, the report suggests he could serve as a short-term solution for the Italian club, though details remain unclear on whether negotiations will progress further.

Cult of CalcioRead original →
Svilar eager for Roma and Champions League: intensive training ahead of summer retreat
Squad NewsClub News AI
4d ago

Svilar eager for Roma and Champions League: intensive training ahead of summer retreat

Mile Svilar is preparing for the upcoming season with renewed determination to compete for AS Roma in both domestic and European competitions. The goalkeeper is undergoing intense training sessions as the club prepares for its summer retreat, signaling his readiness to be a key figure for the Giallorossi in the campaign ahead. Svilar's focus on pre-season conditioning reflects Roma's ambitions to challenge for silverware and establish themselves as Champions League contenders. His commitment during this preparatory phase underscores his importance to head coach Gian Piero Gasperini's plans for the new season. The club is prioritizing fitness and tactical development as players return for their summer training schedule. Details regarding the specific timing and location of Roma's summer retreat remain unclear, though the club is evidently prioritizing comprehensive preparation ahead of competitive fixtures. Svilar's determination to deliver for Roma highlights the squad's collective mindset as they look to make an impact both domestically and on the European stage.

Roma Reject Multiple Transfer Offers, Lean on UEFA Extension
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
4d ago

Roma Reject Multiple Transfer Offers, Lean on UEFA Extension

Roma successfully resisted attempts by rival clubs to acquire key players on June 30th. Juventus approached the club for Mile Svilar, while Inter and Porto both made offers for Niccolò Pisilli. Additionally, Matías Soulé rejected a move to Saudi Arabia, with his agent expressing frustration over how the negotiations were handled. Despite pressure from multiple directions, Roma declined all approaches and maintained their squad. UEFA has granted Roma a one-month extension on the deadline for including player sales in their financial records due to World Cup scheduling, though this grace period does not apply to new acquisitions. Head coach Gian Piero Gasperini has made clear his desire to retain Wesley, Evan N'Dicka, and Manu Koné as cornerstones of his squad, and the club hierarchy has prioritized keeping the manager satisfied. Roma intends to argue to UEFA that they can manage financial losses through peripheral transactions if necessary. Failure to meet Financial Fair Play requirements could expose Roma to fines exceeding €10 million and squad restrictions in 2027–28, though harsher penalties are considered unlikely. The club's strategy appears focused on retaining its top-tier players while strengthening the squad around the margins in the coming weeks.

Cult of CalcioRead original →
Feedback