← All stories
VAR review on Manchester United-Roma: Heaven penalty for handball
·3 November 2026·2h ago

VAR review on Manchester United-Roma: Heaven penalty for handball

Source: Forza Roma

Roma's Champions League League Phase fixture at Old Trafford against Manchester United has been reviewed in a VAR breakdown, with the clearest talking point a penalty awarded to Roma after a handball by Heaven on Soulé's shot in the 16th minute. Referee Gil Manzano pointed to the spot, and a silent check from the VAR confirmed the decision.

The match is the fourth matchday of the Champions League League Phase. Manzano is refereeing, assisted by Ayuso and Barbero, with Munuera as fourth official. At VAR, Del Cerro Grande is working with Fernandez as AVAR. The game produced a busy disciplinary record. Heaven was booked in the 70th minute for a hard challenge on Soulé, and Malen was cautioned in the 42nd minute for holding back Baleba. Lulli was booked in the 35th minute for a handball that stopped an attacking move.

The second penalty decision came in the 55th minute, when Cunha stumbled inside the box and Manzano pointed to the spot. The contact that was not there between Mancini's legs and the striker's was confirmed by VAR. In the 57th minute, Vásquez made a save, but Cristante cleared, and Manzano ordered the penalty retaken for a slight encroachment by Cristante as Bruno Fernandes was about to strike.

Soulé and Bruno Fernandes were both booked in the 19th minute after sparks flew following a throw-in. Soulé was angry that the Portuguese player had not put the ball out with Rensch down on the pitch. Maguire was booked in the 78th minute for a slap on Castro. In the 85th minute, Maguire brought down Castro by the leg, and Manzano spared him a second yellow card. Cunha was sent off in the 90th minute for a second booking after a dangerous challenge on Balerdi.

● AI Generated Summary

This summary was generated by an AI model. Always read the source for complete and accurate information.

Testo Originale / Source Text

“I giallorossi fanno tappa a Old Trafford per affrontare il Manchester United nella quarta giornata di League Phase di Champions. Ad arbitrare la sfida c'è spagnolo Gil Manzano, con assistenti Ayuso e Barbero. Il quarto uomo è Munuera, mentre al VAR ci sono Del Cerro Grande con Fernandez AVAR. 90'…”

Read the full article in Italian at Forza Roma.

Read original on Forza Roma →

More Match Report

Gasperini to speak after Roma's comeback defeat to Manchester United
Press ConferenceMatch Report● AI
just now

Gasperini to speak after Roma's comeback defeat to Manchester United

Gian Piero Gasperini is due to speak shortly on television and at a press conference after Roma lost a match to Manchester United from a comeback position. The defeat is a heavy one in the league table, with Roma slipping to 19th place on 4 points. The result leaves the club near the foot of the standings, and the loss of ground in the table makes it a painful setback for the squad at this stage of the season. Gasperini's comments will be broadcast on TV and given at the press conference following the match, where he is expected to address the defeat and the club's position.

Soulé and Malen make Premier League... no, European history: Roma's two goals in 17 minutes at Old Trafford
EuropeMatch Report● AI
2h ago

Soulé and Malen make Premier League... no, European history: Roma's two goals in 17 minutes at Old Trafford

Matías Soulé and Donyell Malen have made history for Roma at Old Trafford, with the two forwards scoring in the space of 17 minutes against Manchester United. According to OptaJoe, no away side had ever scored two goals in 17 minutes at Old Trafford in a major European competition. It is a record that is painful for the Red Devils but a positive one for Roma and Gian Piero Gasperini. The result deepens the crisis at Manchester United, who are struggling under Carrick, with the English coach increasingly close to being dismissed. For Roma, the performance marks a significant away success in Europe and adds to a campaign that has now seen one of the most striking statistical achievements at the stadium. Soulé and Malen were the two players behind the record, and their goals are the defining detail of the night for the Giallorossi. The historic nature of the feat, confirmed by OptaJoe, underlines how rare such a quick double has been for a visiting team in a major European competition at the ground.

Malen in record-breaking form as Roma lead Manchester United early on in Champions League
Match ReportEurope● AI
2h ago

Malen in record-breaking form as Roma lead Manchester United early on in Champions League

Roma opened a two-goal lead at Manchester United in the first 20 minutes of their Champions League league-phase fixture, with the second goal scored by Donyell Malen from the penalty spot. The Dutch forward also reached a personal European milestone. Malen is one of five players with six or more goal involvements so far in this Champions League, having scored four goals and provided two assists. That surpasses his previous European record, set with PSV in the 2020/21 Europa League. The Italian original was a match preview and early report that ran alongside Roma's Telegram and WhatsApp channels for free news updates, which do not form part of the match story. Roma dominated the opening exchanges in Manchester, showing personality on the road against the English side.

More on Donyell Malen

Player profile →
Soulé and Malen make Premier League... no, European history: Roma's two goals in 17 minutes at Old Trafford
EuropeMatch Report● AI
2h ago

Soulé and Malen make Premier League... no, European history: Roma's two goals in 17 minutes at Old Trafford

Matías Soulé and Donyell Malen have made history for Roma at Old Trafford, with the two forwards scoring in the space of 17 minutes against Manchester United. According to OptaJoe, no away side had ever scored two goals in 17 minutes at Old Trafford in a major European competition. It is a record that is painful for the Red Devils but a positive one for Roma and Gian Piero Gasperini. The result deepens the crisis at Manchester United, who are struggling under Carrick, with the English coach increasingly close to being dismissed. For Roma, the performance marks a significant away success in Europe and adds to a campaign that has now seen one of the most striking statistical achievements at the stadium. Soulé and Malen were the two players behind the record, and their goals are the defining detail of the night for the Giallorossi. The historic nature of the feat, confirmed by OptaJoe, underlines how rare such a quick double has been for a visiting team in a major European competition at the ground.

Malen in record-breaking form as Roma lead Manchester United early on in Champions League
Match ReportEurope● AI
2h ago

Malen in record-breaking form as Roma lead Manchester United early on in Champions League

Roma opened a two-goal lead at Manchester United in the first 20 minutes of their Champions League league-phase fixture, with the second goal scored by Donyell Malen from the penalty spot. The Dutch forward also reached a personal European milestone. Malen is one of five players with six or more goal involvements so far in this Champions League, having scored four goals and provided two assists. That surpasses his previous European record, set with PSV in the 2020/21 Europa League. The Italian original was a match preview and early report that ran alongside Roma's Telegram and WhatsApp channels for free news updates, which do not form part of the match story. Roma dominated the opening exchanges in Manchester, showing personality on the road against the English side.

Malen says Roma are ready for Manchester United but must be careful
Match ReportEurope● AI
3h ago

Malen says Roma are ready for Manchester United but must be careful

Donyell Malen says Roma are ready for their Champions League fixture at Manchester United, which is the fourth matchday of the league phase, but insists the squad must be careful. Asked about United's current form, Malen said they are not getting the best results but are a good side, so Roma have to be careful. Malen is an established part of the Roma squad, and his comments come ahead of a difficult away trip in the Champions League. He is looking forward to the occasion at Old Trafford and sees the match as a test of Roma's focus against a side that remains dangerous despite its recent results. Asked whether Roma are ready, Malen said: "Yes, we are ready. I can't wait to play. It will be a great evening." On the numbers he has posted, he said: "Yes, those are good numbers. I hope I can add to them today." Asked about the atmosphere at Old Trafford, he said: "It's a fantastic stadium, I can't wait to play there. It will be a great evening."

More on Emanuele Lulli

Player profile →
Rensch goes off injured as Roma lead Manchester United at Old Trafford
InjuryEurope● AI
2h ago

Rensch goes off injured as Roma lead Manchester United at Old Trafford

Roma are two goals up at Old Trafford after 20 minutes of the Champions League league-phase match against Manchester United, but Gian Piero Gasperini has been dealt another injury blow. Devyne Rensch collapsed to the ground in the 20th minute with a muscle problem and was unable to continue. Emanuele Lulli came on in his place. The setback adds to Gasperini's growing list of injured players. Roma have made a strong start, and the loss of Rensch comes at a time when the squad is already stretched. His condition will be assessed in the coming days. The Dutch defender was forced off early in the first half after going down with what appeared to be a muscular problem. Roma's opening 20 minutes were described as extraordinary, with the Giallorossi already ahead by two goals before the injury took its toll.

Rensch goes off injured after 22 minutes at Manchester United; Lulli makes Champions League debut
InjuryMatch Report● AI
2h ago

Rensch goes off injured after 22 minutes at Manchester United; Lulli makes Champions League debut

Roma have suffered another injury blow at Old Trafford, with Devyne Rensch forced off after just 22 minutes of the Manchester United clash. The Dutch right-back, who had been handed a surprise start from the first minute on the right flank, was replaced by Emanuele Lulli, who is making his Champions League debut. The problem appears to be muscular. The setback comes only hours after Pierluigi Gollini was ruled out just a few hours before kickoff, meaning Roma have been hit by a string of late absences before a ball was kicked. Rensch's exit leaves the Giallorossi having to adjust on the right side of defence while already short in goal. Rensch joined Roma from Ajax in January 2025, and his early departure is a concern for a side already navigating a difficult run of fitness problems in Manchester.

Manchester United 1-2 Roma: Soulè and Malen Put Roma Ahead at Old Trafford
Match ReportEurope● AI
4h ago

Manchester United 1-2 Roma: Soulè and Malen Put Roma Ahead at Old Trafford

Roma led Manchester United 2-0 at half-time in their Champions League league-phase fourth matchday clash at Old Trafford, with Paulo Dybala's teammate Matías Soulé and Donyell Malen on the scoresheet. Soulé opened the scoring in the 11th minute after a fine pass from Mora, and Malen doubled the lead from the penalty spot in the 17th minute after Heaven handled Soulé's shot. Bruno Fernandes pulled one back for United in the 57th minute, after the hosts had been handed a penalty that Vásquez saved before the referee ordered a retake. Roma came into the game with four points from their first three European matches, following a convincing win over Slovan Bratislava, while United, under Michael Carrick, were on three points and in a difficult spell. Gian Piero Gasperini made changes to his starting lineup. Gollini was ruled out at the last minute, so Vásquez started in goal. Balerdi came in for Ndicka at centre-back, and Rensch won the battle for the right-back spot over Molina. Malen and Soulé were confirmed up front with Mora in support. On the United side, Lammens started in goal, with Mbeumo, Bruno Fernandes and Diallo behind Cunha. Roma dominated the first half and had further chances to extend their lead. Soulé came close with a left-foot effort that went narrowly wide, and Cristante released Malen, whose right-foot shot was tipped away by Lammens. Bruno Fernandes also fired over from a good position. Roma's defence was tested after Rensch was forced off in the 22nd minute, with Lulli coming on in his place. Malen was booked in the 41st minute for a foul, and Lulli was booked in the 35th minute for handball. Soulé and Bruno Fernandes were both shown yellow cards in the 20th minute after a flare-up on the pitch. In the second half, Gasperini brought on Pisilli in place of Mora at the restart. Baleba was injured in the 47th minute and was replaced by Tielemans in the 50th minute. United then received a penalty in the 55th minute, when Mancini's arm contacted the ball and Cunha went down under contact. Vásquez saved Bruno Fernandes' spot kick, but the referee ordered it to be retaken, and Fernandes made no mistake the second time, in the 57th minute. Shortly afterwards, Mbeumo struck the woodwork twice. By the 65th minute, the momentum had shifted towards United, with the home crowd lifted and United reinvigorated. The match was refereed by Jesús Gil Manzano from Spain, with Guadalupe Porras Ayuso and Diego Barbero as assistants, Juan Martínez Munuera as fourth official, and Carlos del Cerro Grande on VAR. The match remained in progress at the time of the live coverage, and Roma's position in the league phase will depend on how the second half ends.

GialloRossi.netRead original →

More on Gianluca Mancini

Player profile →
Manchester United 1-2 Roma: Soulè and Malen Put Roma Ahead at Old Trafford
Match ReportEurope● AI
4h ago

Manchester United 1-2 Roma: Soulè and Malen Put Roma Ahead at Old Trafford

Roma led Manchester United 2-0 at half-time in their Champions League league-phase fourth matchday clash at Old Trafford, with Paulo Dybala's teammate Matías Soulé and Donyell Malen on the scoresheet. Soulé opened the scoring in the 11th minute after a fine pass from Mora, and Malen doubled the lead from the penalty spot in the 17th minute after Heaven handled Soulé's shot. Bruno Fernandes pulled one back for United in the 57th minute, after the hosts had been handed a penalty that Vásquez saved before the referee ordered a retake. Roma came into the game with four points from their first three European matches, following a convincing win over Slovan Bratislava, while United, under Michael Carrick, were on three points and in a difficult spell. Gian Piero Gasperini made changes to his starting lineup. Gollini was ruled out at the last minute, so Vásquez started in goal. Balerdi came in for Ndicka at centre-back, and Rensch won the battle for the right-back spot over Molina. Malen and Soulé were confirmed up front with Mora in support. On the United side, Lammens started in goal, with Mbeumo, Bruno Fernandes and Diallo behind Cunha. Roma dominated the first half and had further chances to extend their lead. Soulé came close with a left-foot effort that went narrowly wide, and Cristante released Malen, whose right-foot shot was tipped away by Lammens. Bruno Fernandes also fired over from a good position. Roma's defence was tested after Rensch was forced off in the 22nd minute, with Lulli coming on in his place. Malen was booked in the 41st minute for a foul, and Lulli was booked in the 35th minute for handball. Soulé and Bruno Fernandes were both shown yellow cards in the 20th minute after a flare-up on the pitch. In the second half, Gasperini brought on Pisilli in place of Mora at the restart. Baleba was injured in the 47th minute and was replaced by Tielemans in the 50th minute. United then received a penalty in the 55th minute, when Mancini's arm contacted the ball and Cunha went down under contact. Vásquez saved Bruno Fernandes' spot kick, but the referee ordered it to be retaken, and Fernandes made no mistake the second time, in the 57th minute. Shortly afterwards, Mbeumo struck the woodwork twice. By the 65th minute, the momentum had shifted towards United, with the home crowd lifted and United reinvigorated. The match was refereed by Jesús Gil Manzano from Spain, with Guadalupe Porras Ayuso and Diego Barbero as assistants, Juan Martínez Munuera as fourth official, and Carlos del Cerro Grande on VAR. The match remained in progress at the time of the live coverage, and Roma's position in the league phase will depend on how the second half ends.

GialloRossi.netRead original →
Gasperini names Vásquez in goal as Roma travel to Manchester United in Champions League
Match ReportEurope● AI
4h ago

Gasperini names Vásquez in goal as Roma travel to Manchester United in Champions League

Roma head to Old Trafford to face Manchester United, coached by Carrick, in the fourth matchday of the Champions League league phase, with Gasperini forced into a change in goal. Pierluigi Gollini has withdrawn at the last hour, so Devis Vásquez starts. Leonardo Balerdi comes in at centre-back instead of Evan N'Dicka, and Devyne Rensch is the right wing-back. Nahuel Molina and Emanuele Lulli are on the bench. The midfield and attack are unchanged, with Rodrigo Mora starting from the first minute. Manchester United line up in a 4-2-3-1 formation, with Lammens in goal, Yoro, Maguire, Heaven and Dalot in defence, Mainoo and Baleba in midfield, Cunha, Fernandes and Diallo behind Mbeumo. Roma play a 3-4-2-1, with Vásquez; Mancini, Balerdi and Hermoso at the back; Rensch, Cristante, de Roon and Wesley in midfield; Soulé and Mora in support of Malen up front. United's bench includes Darlow, Heaton, Mazraoui, De Ligt, Martinez, Mount, Tielemans, Santos, Lacey, Fletcher, Amass and Zirkzee. Roma's bench features De Marzi, Koulierakis, N'Dicka, Pisilli, Ghilardi, Molina, Lulli, Di Nunzio and Castro.

Manchester United vs Roma: probable line-ups, Vásquez to start in place of Gollini
EuropeSquad News● AI
5h ago

Manchester United vs Roma: probable line-ups, Vásquez to start in place of Gollini

Roma travel to Old Trafford tonight for their fourth League Phase match of the Champions League, facing Manchester United under head coach Michael Carrick, with Gian Piero Gasperini's side looking for points after a comprehensive win over Slovan Bratislava. Roma have four points from their first three European matches, while United sit on three points and are going through a very difficult spell. Gollini has been ruled out, and Devis Vásquez will start in goal in his place. The Roma line-up is a 3-4-2-1 formation: Vásquez; Balerdi, N'Dicka, Hermoso; Molina, De Roon, Cristante, Wesley; Soulé, Mora; Malen. Leonardo Balerdi is pushing Mancini for a place in the defence, while Rodrigo Mora is set for a starting spot. On the bench for Roma are De Marzi, Gollini, Koulierakis, Mancini, Ghilardi, Lulli, Rensch, Di Nunzio, Pisilli and Castro. Manchester United line up in a 4-2-3-1: Lammens; Yoro, Maguire, Lisandro Martinez, Dalot; Mainoo, Andrey Santos; Mbeumo, Tielemans, Bruno Fernandes; Cunha. Their substitutes are Darlow, Heaton, De Ligt, Mazraoui, Heaven, Amass, Baleba, Mount, Diallo, Zirkzee and Lacey. The referee is Jesús Gil Manzano (Spain), assisted by Guadalupe Porras Ayuso and Diego Barbero, with Juan Martínez Munuera as fourth official. The VAR is Carlos del Cerro Grande, with Guillermo Cuadra Fernandez as assistant VAR.

GialloRossi.netRead original →
Feedback