Referee analysis: Rensch goal valid, Roma penalty justified, but questions over Mancini incident
Match Report·11 May 2026·47d ago

Referee analysis: Rensch goal valid, Roma penalty justified, but questions over Mancini incident

Source: Forza Roma

Referee Gianpaolo Calvarese has analysed a contentious match between Roma and Parma, offering his verdict on several disputed moments. In the first half, Roma appealed for two penalties: the first came when Circati made contact with Dybala's arm, but Calvarese assessed that the defender's objective was to create space for the ball rather than obstruct play, making it non-punishable. The second involved Valenti's challenge on Mancini from a falling ball; while contact occurred, the VAR did not intervene because the defender simultaneously cleared the ball.

In the second half, the annulment of Pellegrino's goal drew heavy criticism after Troilo's movement interfered with Svilar's dive. A silent VAR check examined whether Mancini's arm made contact as Rensch scored the 2–2, but Calvarese determined the impact was with the defender's flank and would not have been punishable regardless. The final flashpoint was the penalty awarded to Roma following an on-field review: Rensch gained an advantage over Britschgi through body-to-body contact as he moved into position ahead of his opponent, which constituted a foul.

Calvarese's analysis provides context for the match's volatile nature and the VAR's intervention points throughout.

● AI Generated Summary

This summary was generated by an AI model. Always read the source for complete and accurate information.

Testo Originale / Source Text

Machine-scraped Italian — paste into Google Translate for a full read.

Calvarese: “Rensch è avanti, giusto il rigore. Dubbi su Mancini” - Forzaroma.info Forzaroma.infoI migliori video scelti dal nostro canaleforzaroma rassegna stampa il tempo Calvarese: “Rensch è avanti, giusto il rigore. Dubbi su Mancini”Il TempoCalvarese: “Rensch è avanti, giusto il rigore. Dubbi su Mancini”Getty imagesNel primo tempo la Roma chiede due rigori, poi la rete di Rensch, il gol annullato a Pellegrino e il penalty assegnato ai giallorossi nel recupero Redazione 11 maggio 2026 (modifica il 11 maggio 2026 | 08:11) Partita e animic concitati a Parma, con tanti episodi arbitrali da commentare. Su 'Il Tempo' l'analisi di Gianpaolo Calvarese: "Nel primo tempo la Roma chiede due rigori. Il primo: vero che Circati sbilancia Dybala con un braccio, ma l'obiettivo del difensore è farsi spazio nella ricerca del pallone, il contatto non è punibile. Più complesso il secondo. Rischia Valenti, che su un pallone spiovente rifila un calcione a Mancini. Sembra che l'argentino colpisca la gamba dell'avversario ma il VAR non interviene perché, quasi contemporaneamente al contatto, il difensore riesce anche a rinviare il pallone. Nella ripresa, molto contestato l'annullamento del gol di Pellegrino: il movimento di Troilo interferisce con il tuffo di Svilar. Silent check sul 2-2 di Rensch per un possibile tocco di braccio di Mancini da terra. L'impatto sembra col fianco, ma anche se fosse stato col braccio non sarebbe stato punibile. Poi il rigore assegnato alla Roma con OFR. Rensch va in vantaggio su Britschgi: il corpo a corpo, nel momento in cui Rensch prende posizione e va davanti all’avversario, diventa falloso".Leggi anche Squadra confermata, davanti c’è Soulé Roma non fermarti © RIPRODUZIONE RISERVATA

Read original on Forza Roma

More Match Report

Malen Scoreless as Netherlands Advance; Round of 16 Clash with Morocco Looms
Match Report AI
1d ago

Malen Scoreless as Netherlands Advance; Round of 16 Clash with Morocco Looms

The Netherlands defeated Tunisia 3–1 in their final group match, securing first place and advancing to the round of 16. Goals came from an own goal by Skhiri, Brobbey, and van Hecke, while Mastouri scored for Tunisia. Donyell Malen, the AS Roma winger, played from the start on the right flank but remained goalless, being substituted in the 72nd minute for Summerville. Tunisia finished the tournament with zero points. The Netherlands will face Morocco in the round of 16 on 30 June at 3 a.m. Italian time. This sets up a Roma connection, as both sides are managed by figures linked to the Giallorossi. The match represents a significant moment for Malen, who will be eager to end his tournament campaign with a goal after failing to find the net in the group stage. Malen's performance comes amid Roma's broader mercato activity, with the club reportedly consolidating its squad ahead of the new season.

Koeman defends Malen after halftime substitution in Netherlands victory over Sweden
Match ReportSquad News AI
6d ago

Koeman defends Malen after halftime substitution in Netherlands victory over Sweden

Netherlands head coach Ronald Koeman explained his decision to replace Roma winger Donyell Malen at halftime during the Oranje's 5–1 win over Sweden in a World Cup qualifier. Malen was deployed on the wing in the first half but struggled with defensive duties as Sweden adjusted to a four-defender formation, prompting the change. Koeman said: "The first half concluded with a weaker phase of play, partly because Sweden began playing with four defenders. Our wingers kept pressing their centre-back, whereas usually the number 9s and 10s do that. Consequently, we found ourselves in serious trouble a couple of times. The defensive phase was also the reason for Malen's substitution; I believe Summerville is better defensively. We often talk with players about the need to recognise changes on the pitch more quickly. I understand the substitution is difficult for Donyell, but this is high-level football. A team performance is expected." The Roma striker had failed to score in pre-tournament friendlies and his opening match against Japan before facing Sweden. Koeman was quick to reassure supporters and the player himself, stating that Malen is not being scapegoated and may return as a centre-forward in upcoming matches. He also noted that striker Brobbey had experienced a minor hamstring issue, explaining the need for rotation.

Netherlands vs Sweden: Malen moves to the wing as Koeman selects Brobbey as striker
Squad NewsMatch Report AI
7d ago

Netherlands vs Sweden: Malen moves to the wing as Koeman selects Brobbey as striker

Donyell Malen will play on the right wing for the Netherlands in their Group B match against Sweden, a fixture already crucial after drawing 0–0 against Japan in their opening game. Coach Ronald Koeman has reshaped the attacking setup, positioning Gakpo on the left, Malen on the right, and Brobbey of Sunderland as the central striker. This marks a change from the first match, where Malen operated in a more central role. Koeman's tactical adjustment aims to generate more attacking opportunities as the Netherlands seeks vital goals in what is effectively a knockout stage match. Malen, who plays for AS Roma in Serie A, will be crucial to the team's attacking threat on the flank rather than leading the line. The strategic shift reflects Koeman's desire to optimize the team's attacking balance while still utilizing Malen's pace and technical abilities in a different capacity. The match against Sweden kicks off at 19:00 local time and represents a critical encounter for the Netherlands' tournament progression.

More on Paulo Dybala

Player profile →
Pedullà: Roma working behind the scenes on multiple fronts; Koné's agent makes position clear
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
8h ago

Pedullà: Roma working behind the scenes on multiple fronts; Koné's agent makes position clear

Transfer analyst Alfredo Pedullà has outlined Roma's activity across several key areas of the squad. Paulo Dybala is close to signing a new contract, with Gasperini prioritizing the renewal. Celik's situation is reportedly almost finalized, while a further meeting is needed to resolve Lorenzo Pellegrini's terms. Pedullà confirmed that Koné's agent has communicated directly to Roma: "No to speculation, there must not be intermediaries, people bringing offers. I am the agent and I will bring the offers." Roma values the midfielder at a minimum of €45 million including bonuses, though the situation could shift rapidly. On the attacking front, Greenwood is on Gasperini's list but is not the only target under consideration. Pedullà emphasized there is no active negotiation or meeting yet scheduled, suggesting Roma is exploring options quietly. Other names under review remain unconfirmed, while Paixao, Nusa, and others have been ruled out. The club is conducting business away from public scrutiny across recruitment priorities, with potential developments in Matías Soulé's situation also possible. The renewal of Dybala and acquisition of attacking reinforcements represent key priorities as Gasperini shapes his squad.

Foti reflects on Roma tenure under Mourinho, reveals role in Dybala chant
OpinionClub News AI
10h ago

Foti reflects on Roma tenure under Mourinho, reveals role in Dybala chant

Salvatore Foti, who served as assistant coach to José Mourinho during his time at Roma, has discussed his period with the club. Foti commented on a match in Budapest, stating he would have preferred a clear 3-0 defeat. He also revealed his involvement in initiating a chant related to Paulo Dybala. Foti's remarks offer insight into his experience working alongside Mourinho at Roma, touching on both tactical moments and fan engagement during his tenure with the Giallorossi.

Pellegrini renewal on hold as Romano joins Cagliari; Dybala deal nears completion
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
1d ago

Pellegrini renewal on hold as Romano joins Cagliari; Dybala deal nears completion

Roma's summer transfer activity is intensifying, with multiple moves in development. Lorenzo Pellegrini's contract renewal is not currently a priority for the club; while the midfielder visited the training ground on Monday to discuss an extension, any formal negotiation with the board will not take place until July. The focus instead shifts to Paulo Dybala, whose renewal is progressing and drawing closer to completion, bolstered by head coach Gian Piero Gasperini's backing. The Friedkin Group aims to finalize Dybala's new deal by 30 June. Meanwhile, Alessandro Romano's departure has been confirmed: the 2006-born midfielder will join Cagliari for a reported 5 million euros plus performance-based bonuses that could reach 6.5 million, with a conditional purchase obligation clause included. The Romano transfer provides financial relief ahead of Roma's 30 June accounting deadline. Real Betis has also reportedly tabled an offer of 15 million euros for an unnamed Roma player involving a loan with a purchase option, though details remain unclear.

More on Gianluca Mancini

Player profile →
Stephan El Shaarawy weds Ludovica Pagani in ceremony attended by Roma teammates
Club NewsSquad News AI
2h ago

Stephan El Shaarawy weds Ludovica Pagani in ceremony attended by Roma teammates

Stephan El Shaarawy, Roma's forward, married influencer and DJ Ludovica Pagani on 27 June at Villa Aldobrandini in Frascati. The couple had already undergone a civil ceremony in Rome in May but celebrated their religious marriage with family, friends, and numerous celebrities. El Shaarawy will officially become a free agent on 1 July following the conclusion of Roma's qualifying campaign for the Champions League, during which he scored the second goal in a victory against Verona. Several of El Shaarawy's Roma teammates attended the celebration, described as his closest companions: Gollini, Mancini, Cristante, and Pellegrini. The latter was reportedly juggling attendance at two weddings on the same day, as confirmed on social media by his wife. The guest list extended beyond the Roma contingent to include prominent figures from music and sport, with Pagani's side of the celebration drawing entertainment and athletics personalities. Guests included singer Elettra Lamborghini, fellow musician Giulia Penna, and basketball player Valentina Vignali, who documented the ceremony's most memorable moments on Instagram. El Shaarawy and Pagani's relationship began in 2020 and has now reached formal marriage status following the festivities at the historic villa.

Greenwood commits to Roma after talks with Gasperini; Koné's Premier move distant; Engels eyed
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
2h ago

Greenwood commits to Roma after talks with Gasperini; Koné's Premier move distant; Engels eyed

Mason Greenwood, the Marseille attacker, has reportedly agreed to join AS Roma following direct conversations with head coach Gian Piero Gasperini three weeks ago. The Friedkin Group is in negotiations with Marseille owner McCourt, with an offer of €40 million plus bonuses expected to be tabled in the coming week. Greenwood's father, Andrew, who acts as his agent, was present during the initial talks with Gasperini. The player has rejected interest from Fenerbahce to pursue the Roma move. Gasperini is also searching for a physically dominant midfielder with strong tactical awareness, with Freuler and Kessié identified as targets available on free transfers. Regarding other transfer activity, Aurélien Koné's prospects of joining a Premier League club are receding, with Arsenal's interest cooling while Chelsea focuses elsewhere. Roma continue to monitor Engels from Celtic, valued at €20–25 million. In separate Roma news, El Shaarawy was recently married, with several Roma players including Mancini and Cristante attending the wedding. Key developments are expected in the coming week as the Greenwood negotiations intensify. The transfer window remains active for the club as Gasperini shapes his squad for the new season.

El Shaarawy weds Pagani with Roma teammates in attendance
Club News AI
3h ago

El Shaarawy weds Pagani with Roma teammates in attendance

El Shaarawy, the former Roma attacker, married influencer Pagani in a ceremony attended by several of his ex-teammates from the club. Current Roma players Gianluca Mancini and Bryan Cristante were present at the wedding, alongside Pierluigi Gollini. El Shaarawy departed Roma during the recent transfer window, ending his association with the Giallorossi. The wedding brought together members of the Roma squad in a social gathering outside of competitive football. The presence of multiple current and recent players underscores the bonds formed within the club. El Shaarawy had been a significant figure at Roma before his exit, and the attendance of Mancini and Cristante reflects the camaraderie that exists among the playing group.

More on Mile Svilar

Player profile →
Roma figures comment on Malen's international form and Svilar's future
OpinionSquad News AI
13h ago

Roma figures comment on Malen's international form and Svilar's future

Roma legend Roberto Pruzzo and commentator Marcacci have weighed in on two key squad matters. Pruzzo addressed Donyell Malen's performance with the Dutch national team, stating that what matters most is the winger's motivation upon returning to Trigoria. Marcacci expressed hope that speculation about Mile Svilar's departure does not gain traction. The comments reflect broader concerns about maintaining squad morale and stability as players balance international commitments with club duties.

Juventus explores signing Svilar; Roma sets firm price and refuses to sell
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
14h ago

Juventus explores signing Svilar; Roma sets firm price and refuses to sell

Juventus has made enquiries about Mile Svilar, Roma's goalkeeper, but Roma has rejected any approach and established a asking price to retain the player. Despite financial pressures related to player sales, Gasperini and D'Amico have prioritized keeping Svilar as a cornerstone of the club's defence. The goalkeeper remains one of Roma's key assets under the new sporting structure, and the club appears determined to build their project around him rather than cash in on a summer departure.

Svilar rejection from Juventus; Mancini-Inter talk dismissed as agent positioning
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
1d ago

Svilar rejection from Juventus; Mancini-Inter talk dismissed as agent positioning

Juventus reportedly inquired about Roma goalkeeper Mile Svilar approximately one month ago but withdrew interest after learning the asking price. According to reports, a Juventus intermediary asked Roma representatives about Svilar's availability, and when told the price would be 50 million euros or above, Juventus ended the discussion and moved on to other targets. Separately, speculation surrounding defender Gianluca Mancini and Inter Milan has been characterized as agent positioning rather than a formal transfer approach. While Inter reportedly admires Mancini, no official offer was made. Mancini's contract situation remains secure—he is set to sign a renewal at Roma and has not requested a departure. The player wants to remain at the club, and there is no indication he has sought a move away. Both situations highlight typical summer transfer window dynamics: Juventus conducting preliminary checks on available targets before deciding on priorities, and agent activity exploring the market even as key players are committed to their current clubs. Roma's position on both players appears stable, with Svilar and Mancini expected to remain at the Stadio Olimpico.

Feedback