Transfer NewsAnalysis● AI
3h agoDybala renewal: the case for saying yes to the Joya
Roma must decide whether to extend Paulo Dybala, whose contract runs out in June 2027, and the debate inside the club has split into two camps. Those in favour want to keep him at all costs, while those who point to his minutes and injuries argue he should be allowed to leave. The article argues for a third path: renewing him, but with restraint and awareness.
Supporters start from head coach Gian Piero Gasperini, who has never hidden his view that Dybala is an important part of the project. He defended the player when it seemed he might go elsewhere, accepted a reduction in his salary and keeps saying that when he is available, Dybala makes the difference. Alongside that technical trust sits the commercial value: Dybala remains one of the most recognisable and marketable faces of Roma. In the club's centenary year, that is not a minor detail but an asset. Finally, there is his pure quality. Even at 33, few in the squad can create overloads and hold the ball the way he does.
Sceptics have serious arguments too. The first is consistency. His minutes are falling, injuries have returned, and in his absences the team has shown it can produce goals and results. Matías Soulé is establishing himself and Rodrigo Mora is growing, and both are claiming and demanding space, leading some to ask whether it still makes sense to invest in a player who no longer guarantees regularity. The second argument concerns his age: at 33, with a body that has already shown signs of fragility, the risk of even a one-year contract can look high. According to this view, it would be better to free up space and resources for younger, more durable profiles.
The article accepts that doubts about consistency are legitimate but says they are not enough to close the debate. Dybala is no longer the player around whom the whole build-up is designed, but he can still change the quality level of a match. Gasperini knows this and could use him that way: not as a fixed, untouchable starter, but as a difference-maker. The commercial impact, especially with 2027 in view, strengthens the case further, and the cost, after the salary reduction already accepted, has become sustainable. A one-year renewal, possibly with an option, would bring together the coach's trust, the market value of the name, his evident quality and economic prudence.
Letting him leave on a free transfer would be a costlier renunciation than it appears, the article concludes. Renewing him intelligently, by contrast, is the choice of a club that can tell nostalgia apart from opportunity. Dybala, today, is still an opportunity.