Controversial goal disallowed in Verona-Lecce echoes Atalanta-Roma decision from January
Match Report·25 April 2026·1h ago

Controversial goal disallowed in Verona-Lecce echoes Atalanta-Roma decision from January

Source: Forza Roma

A goal by Edmundsson was disallowed in the final minute of stoppage time during Hellas Verona's match against Lecce on April 25. Referee Massa initially validated the strike but overturned the decision after an on-field review, citing a foul on goalkeeper Falcone. Edmundsson had made contact with Falcone's arm while attempting to block the ball, prompting the VAR check. The disallowed goal has drawn comparisons to a controversial decision from January 3, when Atalanta defeated Roma 1–0 with a goal by Scalvini at the New Balance Arena.

Scalvini's goal generated significant debate because the defender appeared to place both hands on Roma goalkeeper Mile Svilar's face while being obstructed by Rensch, before scoring. Despite a lengthy VAR review, the goal was awarded, sparking criticism from football experts. Luca Marelli, an arbitral expert at DAZN, stated: "Scalvini has both hands on Svilar's face and the goal should have been disallowed. The hands are on the goalkeeper's face before he strikes the ball." The contrast between these two decisions—one disallowed for contact with the goalkeeper, the other awarded despite similar circumstances—has fuelled debate about consistency in refereeing standards.

Andrea De Marco, former referee and institutional relations officer for Serie A and Serie B, defended the Scalvini decision after reviewing the evidence. He explained that officials determined Scalvini struck the ball before contacting Svilar, and that the subsequent contact resulted from the goalkeeper's reaction to being unbalanced.

● AI Generated Summary

This summary was generated by an AI model. Always read the source for complete and accurate information.

Testo Originale / Source Text

Machine-scraped Italian — paste into Google Translate for a full read.

Edmundsson come Scalvini in Atalanta-Roma: ma in Verona-Lecce il gol non è valido - Forzaroma.info Forzaroma.infoI migliori video scelti dal nostro canaleforzaroma news as roma Edmundsson come Scalvini in Atalanta-Roma: ma in Verona-Lecce il gol non è validonews as romaEdmundsson come Scalvini in Atalanta-Roma: ma in Verona-Lecce il gol non è validoGetty ImagesLa rete annullata nell'ultimo minuto di recupero dello scontro salvezza di questa sera al Bentegodi ha suscitato in tanti il ricordo di quanto successo il 3 gennaio a Bergamo Redazione 25 aprile - 23:24 Sta facendo discutere il gol annullato nell'ultimo minuto di recupero dello scontro salvezza tra Hellas Verona e Lecce di questa sera al Bentegodi. Non tanto per la decisione in sé, quanto per un antipatico parallelismo avvenuto ormai quasi cinque mesi fa in Atalanta-Roma. Ma torniamo all'attualità: Verona-Lecce è ferma sullo 0-0 ed Edmundsson trova il gol del vantaggio scaligero al 95'. L'arbitro Massa inizialmente convalida la rete, salvo tornare sui suoi passi e annullare il gol dopo richiamo all'On-Field Review: "Il calciatore numero 5 commette fallo sul portiere, decisione finale gol annullato", l'annuncio del direttore di gara dopo il check. Il motivo? Il fatto che il giocatore dell'Hellas si appoggi con il braccio sinistro al braccio destro di Falcone, fuori dai pali nel tentativo di bloccare la sfera. E il ricordo torna al 3 gennaio, quando alla New Balance Arena l'Atalanta superò 1-0 la Roma con gol di Scalvini. La rete del difensore neroazzurro creò non poche polemiche, visto che Scalvini aveva appoggiato entrambe le mani su Svilar (ostacolato anche da Rensch) prima di depositare la palla in rete. Dopo un lungo check al VAR, comunque, il gol fu regolarmente concesso nonostante il contatto del difensore nerazzurro sul portiere e un possibile tocco con il braccio nell'immediatezza della rete. Anche Luca Marelli, esperto arbitrale di Dazn, si era espresso in modo netto contro quella decisione: "Ci sono entrambe le mani di Scalvini sul volto di Svilar e la rete andava annullata. Le mani sono sulla faccia del portiere prima che lui colpisca il pallone". L'ex arbitro e responsabile dei rapporti istituzionali Can A e B, Andrea De Marco, ha invece dato l'ok alla convalida della rete a OpenVar pochi giorni dopo spiegando: "È stata fatta un'analisi molto accurata, bisogna fare i complimenti al Var Maresca e all'Avar di Paolo. C'erano due aspetti da valutare. Se Scalvini avesse colpito il pallone con il braccio la rete sarebbe stata annullata, ma non c'è evidenza che il calciatore tocchi il pallone con la mano o con il braccio. Poi analizzano il contatto: il calciatore dell'Atalanta colpisce prima il pallone, poi per dinamica il portiere che sbilanciato gli va gli va addosso. Per questo la decisione presa è corretta".Leggi anche Roma, Dybala in campo a Bologna dopo tre mesi ai box: “Felice di essere rientrato” Bologna, Ferguson: “Abbiamo giocato abbastanza bene, ma se prendiamo gol così…” © RIPRODUZIONE RISERVATA

Read original on Forza Roma

More Match Report

Press ConferenceMatch Report AI
3h ago

Gasperini praises Roma's strength after victory at Bologna

Gian Piero Gasperini spoke to media following Roma's 2–0 away win at Bologna, expressing confidence in the club's ambitions and the squad's commitment. The coach acknowledged that while Roma produced a strong first half, the team struggled somewhat in the second period and must improve for upcoming matches. He emphasized the importance of maintaining belief: "We must believe we can win every match. We are in a condition to play a first half like today, in the second we struggled a bit. We must improve on this for the next game." Gasperini highlighted Donyell Malen's impressive performance and noted that absences of Matías Soulé and Paulo Dybala had affected Roma's depth. He also praised a player named El Ayanoui for his display, noting that the player had returned from African Cup of Nations duty with Morocco and had earned recovery time before stepping in. The coach underlined his professional responsibility for tactical matters while expressing gratitude for the club's backing since his arrival. Reflecting on the organisation at Roma, Gasperini stated: "The Roma are a powerful club that will be able to do great things, and I hope to contribute on the technical side." He credited the Friedkin Group with demonstrating consistent trust and commitment to the project from day one, framing the technical direction as his primary focus moving forward.

Bologna-Roma: Dybala returns to action in 2-0 away victory
Match ReportSquad News AI
3h ago

Bologna-Roma: Dybala returns to action in 2-0 away victory

Paulo Dybala made his return to action as AS Roma secured a 2-0 away victory against Bologna in Serie A matchday 34. The Argentine forward expressed satisfaction at playing again with the squad after a period of absence. Dybala's comeback strengthens Roma's midfield options as the season progresses. His return to fitness comes at a significant moment for the Giallorossi as they continue their campaign under head coach Gian Piero Gasperini. Details regarding the exact duration of Dybala's absence and the circumstances of his injury remain unclear from available information.

Dybala Returns to Action for Roma at Bologna After Three-Month Absence
Match ReportInjury AI
4h ago

Dybala Returns to Action for Roma at Bologna After Three-Month Absence

Paulo Dybala made his return to competitive action for Roma on April 25, coming off the bench in the 77th minute of Roma's 2–0 victory at Bologna. The Argentine forward had not played since January 25, when he suffered an injury during Roma's match against Milan at the Olimpico. Between that injury and his return, Dybala underwent meniscal surgery in early March. Dybala's comeback carries significance for Roma's final stretch of the season as the club pursues Champions League qualification or, at minimum, a place in European competition. The forward has approximately four remaining matches to help guide Roma toward their continental ambitions. Following the match, Dybala expressed his satisfaction on social media, posting on Instagram: "Happy to return with the team. Very important victory! Well done everyone." His celebration with supporters underscored the positive mood surrounding his reintegration. While only brief minutes were available to him against Bologna, the appearance serves as a foundation for Dybala to gradually rebuild match fitness and regain his rhythm with the ball and his teammates. Questions about his future beyond the current season remain, but his immediate focus is to contribute during this critical period of Roma's campaign.

More on Mile Svilar

Player profile →
Roma defeat Bologna 2-0 to boost Champions League hopes
Match ReportSerie A AI
4h ago

Roma defeat Bologna 2-0 to boost Champions League hopes

Roma secured a 2-0 victory away at Bologna on 25 April 2026, with both goals arriving in the first half. Donyell Malen opened the scoring with a right-footed finish, and El Aynaoui doubled the lead after receiving an assist from Malen. The result lifted Roma to 61 points in the Serie A standings, moving them to within two points of the Champions League qualification places ahead of the Milan–Juventus fixture. Head coach Gian Piero Gasperini fielded the side for the first time following Claudio Ranieri's departure, with Wesley and Niccolò Pisilli returning to the squad. Roma's aggressive approach from the outset set the tone for the match, with Gasperini's team controlling proceedings throughout the opening period. In the second half, Bologna's Orsolini struck the crossbar with a effort that posed a brief threat to Mile Svilar's goal. Malen was particularly influential in Roma's attacking play, while El Aynaoui made a decisive impact following his entry into the match. The victory represents an important step in Roma's pursuit of European qualification, with the Champions League race remaining competitive in the run-in to the season's conclusion.

Il Messaggero – RomaRead original →
Bologna vs Roma: Official Team Lineups
Match ReportSerie A AI
8h ago

Bologna vs Roma: Official Team Lineups

Roma faced Bologna at the Dall'Ara stadium on April 25, 2026, with Gasperini selecting his starting XI following the previous Saturday's draw against Atalanta. Roma lined up in a 3-4-2-1 formation with Mile Svilar in goal, a back three of Gianluca Mancini, Ndicka, and Hermoso, and Wesley returning to the right flank alongside Celik on the left. The midfield pairing of Cristante and El Aynaoui anchored the side, with Niccolò Pisilli and Matías Soulé deployed behind the sole striker Donyell Malen. Paulo Dybala was among the substitutes after recovering from a recent issue. This fixture represented a critical moment for Roma as the season entered its final stretch, with points still to play for in the title race. Gasperini had also recovered Wesley and defender Rensch from their previous unavailability. The match provided an important test for Roma's form and their prospects for the remainder of the campaign. Bologna, managed by Italiano, fielded a 3-4-3 formation featuring Ravaglia in goal, with Castro and Rowe leading their attacking line. The contest between these two sides carried significance for both teams' final-season ambitions.

Squad NewsSerie A AI
15h ago

Bologna vs Roma: Predicted Lineups — El Aynaoui Challenges El Shaarawy

Roma will travel to Bologna in a crucial Serie A match as the club chases Champions League qualification. Manager Gasperini has several key players available for selection, with Brazilian winger Wesley expected to return to the starting lineup. Paulo Dybala is fit but will begin on the bench, leaving the main tactical question centered on the left-wing position. The primary selection debate involves choosing between El Shaarawy and El Aynaoui on the flank, with midfielder Pisilli's positioning dependent on that decision—he could operate in midfield or shift forward as a number 10 depending on the final lineup. Italian newspapers have published their predicted lineups ahead of the fixture, with most outlets favoring El Shaarawy in the starting XI. Gasperini faces this match during a period of organizational upheaval at the club, though Roma cannot afford further slip-ups if they are to maintain their top-four hopes. The Gazzetta dello Sport, Corriere dello Sport, Il Messaggero, and Il Tempo all predict a 3-4-2-1 formation with El Shaarawy starting, while Tuttosport and Corriere della Sera suggest alternatives involving El Aynaoui in the midfield. The expected lineup includes goalkeeper Svilar, defensive trio of Mancini, Ndicka, and Hermoso, with Malen leading the attack.

More on Devyne Rensch

Player profile →
Bologna-Roma: Match Officials Review, El Aynaoui Suspended for Fiorentina Clash
Match ReportSerie A AI
6h ago

Bologna-Roma: Match Officials Review, El Aynaoui Suspended for Fiorentina Clash

Roma faced Bologna in a crucial late-season encounter at the Dall'Ara stadium, with the match officiated by Marco Di Bello from Brindisi. The match saw several bookings reviewed, including a controversial yellow card for Hermoso in the 46th minute for a foul on Orsolini that appeared minimal, with the Spanish defender protesting the decision. Rensch also received a caution in the 65th minute for a high challenge on Zortea, while a silent VAR check confirmed the booking. The most significant outcome involved El Aynaoui, who received a yellow card in the 68th minute for a foul on Rowe. Since the Moroccan player was already on a booking suspension, this caution rules him out of Roma's next fixture against Fiorentina. The incident highlights the importance of Roma's upcoming schedule as the season reaches its critical final stages, with the club needing to manage squad discipline carefully moving forward.

Bologna vs Roma: Official Team Lineups
Match ReportSerie A AI
8h ago

Bologna vs Roma: Official Team Lineups

Roma faced Bologna at the Dall'Ara stadium on April 25, 2026, with Gasperini selecting his starting XI following the previous Saturday's draw against Atalanta. Roma lined up in a 3-4-2-1 formation with Mile Svilar in goal, a back three of Gianluca Mancini, Ndicka, and Hermoso, and Wesley returning to the right flank alongside Celik on the left. The midfield pairing of Cristante and El Aynaoui anchored the side, with Niccolò Pisilli and Matías Soulé deployed behind the sole striker Donyell Malen. Paulo Dybala was among the substitutes after recovering from a recent issue. This fixture represented a critical moment for Roma as the season entered its final stretch, with points still to play for in the title race. Gasperini had also recovered Wesley and defender Rensch from their previous unavailability. The match provided an important test for Roma's form and their prospects for the remainder of the campaign. Bologna, managed by Italiano, fielded a 3-4-3 formation featuring Ravaglia in goal, with Castro and Rowe leading their attacking line. The contest between these two sides carried significance for both teams' final-season ambitions.

Match ReportSquad News AI
16h ago

Gasperini's Men

AS Roma prepare for a crucial Serie A match against Bologna on Saturday afternoon (18:00 CET) at the Dall'Ara stadium, with head coach Gian Piero Gasperini relying on his core group of experienced players and recent signings. The squad will feature senior figures Hermoso, Mancini, and Cristante alongside summer acquisitions Wesley and Malen. Wesley is expected to start, while Rensch is also available. Dybala travelled with the squad to Emilia but is likely to begin on the bench. Venturino is in the squad despite limited training during the week due to a contusion, and the only tactical question mark involves a choice between El Shaarawy and El Aynaoui for the starting lineup. Roma sit sixth in Serie A, five points behind Juventus—or six in terms of head-to-head record—but remain in contention for Champions League qualification. This weekend's result could prove decisive in that fight. Gasperini has made clear his ambitions remain high, stating: "We are still looking ahead. Then when we cannot do that anymore we will be content with other things." The coach is not ruling out the Champions League race despite Roma's current position. The match represents an important opportunity for the team to close the gap on the top four. Details about squad composition and tactical options remain fluid, with several players awaiting clarification on their futures beyond this season. Gasperini has opted to build around familiar faces and his recent purchases as Roma pursue their European objectives.