Controversial goal disallowed in Verona-Lecce echoes Atalanta-Roma decision from January
Match Report·25 April 2026·45d ago

Controversial goal disallowed in Verona-Lecce echoes Atalanta-Roma decision from January

Source: Forza Roma

A goal by Edmundsson was disallowed in the final minute of stoppage time during Hellas Verona's match against Lecce on April 25. Referee Massa initially validated the strike but overturned the decision after an on-field review, citing a foul on goalkeeper Falcone. Edmundsson had made contact with Falcone's arm while attempting to block the ball, prompting the VAR check. The disallowed goal has drawn comparisons to a controversial decision from January 3, when Atalanta defeated Roma 1–0 with a goal by Scalvini at the New Balance Arena.

Scalvini's goal generated significant debate because the defender appeared to place both hands on Roma goalkeeper Mile Svilar's face while being obstructed by Rensch, before scoring. Despite a lengthy VAR review, the goal was awarded, sparking criticism from football experts. Luca Marelli, an arbitral expert at DAZN, stated: "Scalvini has both hands on Svilar's face and the goal should have been disallowed. The hands are on the goalkeeper's face before he strikes the ball." The contrast between these two decisions—one disallowed for contact with the goalkeeper, the other awarded despite similar circumstances—has fuelled debate about consistency in refereeing standards.

Andrea De Marco, former referee and institutional relations officer for Serie A and Serie B, defended the Scalvini decision after reviewing the evidence. He explained that officials determined Scalvini struck the ball before contacting Svilar, and that the subsequent contact resulted from the goalkeeper's reaction to being unbalanced.

● AI Generated Summary

This summary was generated by an AI model. Always read the source for complete and accurate information.

Testo Originale / Source Text

Machine-scraped Italian — paste into Google Translate for a full read.

Edmundsson come Scalvini in Atalanta-Roma: ma in Verona-Lecce il gol non è valido - Forzaroma.info Forzaroma.infoI migliori video scelti dal nostro canaleforzaroma news as roma Edmundsson come Scalvini in Atalanta-Roma: ma in Verona-Lecce il gol non è validonews as romaEdmundsson come Scalvini in Atalanta-Roma: ma in Verona-Lecce il gol non è validoGetty ImagesLa rete annullata nell'ultimo minuto di recupero dello scontro salvezza di questa sera al Bentegodi ha suscitato in tanti il ricordo di quanto successo il 3 gennaio a Bergamo Redazione 25 aprile - 23:24 Sta facendo discutere il gol annullato nell'ultimo minuto di recupero dello scontro salvezza tra Hellas Verona e Lecce di questa sera al Bentegodi. Non tanto per la decisione in sé, quanto per un antipatico parallelismo avvenuto ormai quasi cinque mesi fa in Atalanta-Roma. Ma torniamo all'attualità: Verona-Lecce è ferma sullo 0-0 ed Edmundsson trova il gol del vantaggio scaligero al 95'. L'arbitro Massa inizialmente convalida la rete, salvo tornare sui suoi passi e annullare il gol dopo richiamo all'On-Field Review: "Il calciatore numero 5 commette fallo sul portiere, decisione finale gol annullato", l'annuncio del direttore di gara dopo il check. Il motivo? Il fatto che il giocatore dell'Hellas si appoggi con il braccio sinistro al braccio destro di Falcone, fuori dai pali nel tentativo di bloccare la sfera. E il ricordo torna al 3 gennaio, quando alla New Balance Arena l'Atalanta superò 1-0 la Roma con gol di Scalvini. La rete del difensore neroazzurro creò non poche polemiche, visto che Scalvini aveva appoggiato entrambe le mani su Svilar (ostacolato anche da Rensch) prima di depositare la palla in rete. Dopo un lungo check al VAR, comunque, il gol fu regolarmente concesso nonostante il contatto del difensore nerazzurro sul portiere e un possibile tocco con il braccio nell'immediatezza della rete. Anche Luca Marelli, esperto arbitrale di Dazn, si era espresso in modo netto contro quella decisione: "Ci sono entrambe le mani di Scalvini sul volto di Svilar e la rete andava annullata. Le mani sono sulla faccia del portiere prima che lui colpisca il pallone". L'ex arbitro e responsabile dei rapporti istituzionali Can A e B, Andrea De Marco, ha invece dato l'ok alla convalida della rete a OpenVar pochi giorni dopo spiegando: "È stata fatta un'analisi molto accurata, bisogna fare i complimenti al Var Maresca e all'Avar di Paolo. C'erano due aspetti da valutare. Se Scalvini avesse colpito il pallone con il braccio la rete sarebbe stata annullata, ma non c'è evidenza che il calciatore tocchi il pallone con la mano o con il braccio. Poi analizzano il contatto: il calciatore dell'Atalanta colpisce prima il pallone, poi per dinamica il portiere che sbilanciato gli va gli va addosso. Per questo la decisione presa è corretta".Leggi anche Roma, Dybala in campo a Bologna dopo tre mesi ai box: “Felice di essere rientrato” Bologna, Ferguson: “Abbiamo giocato abbastanza bene, ma se prendiamo gol così…” © RIPRODUZIONE RISERVATA

Read original on Forza Roma

More Match Report

Match ReportSquad News AI
9h ago

Italy defeats Greece as Pisilli shines for Roma midfielder

Niccolò Pisilli was among the standout performers as Italy defeated Greece in a friendly match under coach Baldini. The AS Roma midfielder featured prominently across two recent friendlies for the Azzurri, following an assist he provided in a previous match against Luxembourg. Pisilli completed 90 minutes in the Greece fixture, earning praise for his display. Pisilli's performances have highlighted his growing importance to the Italian national team setup. His contributions across the two friendlies—including the creative assist in Luxembourg—suggest he is becoming a key option in midfield for the Azzurri. The Roma youngster's ability to perform at international level adds to the squad depth available to Baldini as Italy prepares for upcoming commitments. Pisilli described his approach with the words "heart and pride," reflecting his mentality during the matches. His extended involvement in consecutive friendlies indicates he has secured a prominent role in Baldini's plans moving forward.

Il RomanistaRead original →
Roma to Face AS Cannes in Friedkin Family Friendly on 26 July
Club NewsMatch Report AI
10h ago

Roma to Face AS Cannes in Friedkin Family Friendly on 26 July

AS Roma will play a friendly against AS Cannes on 26 July in Rome, bringing together two clubs owned by the Friedkin family. Both sides enjoyed successful 2025–26 seasons: Roma finished third in Serie A and secured Champions League qualification for the first time under Friedkin ownership after seven years, while Cannes achieved historic promotion to France's third tier (Championnat National 1) for the first time in 15 years. For Gasperini's squad, the match serves as a useful test during the early phase of pre-season preparation before facing stronger opponents. Roma will next play Borussia Dortmund on 15 August. The friendly represents a significant prestige fixture for Cannes but carries particular value for Roma as a controlled stepping stone in their summer training programme ahead of the new campaign. Gasperini commented on the ownership structure, stating: "A greater presence from the Friedkins is needed. With them, Roma is stronger." The fixture highlights the expanding portfolio of the Friedkin Group in European football and offers both clubs important competitive minutes during the off-season.

Malen wastes clear chance in Netherlands friendly ahead of World Cup
Squad NewsMatch Report AI
18h ago

Malen wastes clear chance in Netherlands friendly ahead of World Cup

Donyell Malen squandered a straightforward goal-scoring opportunity in a Netherlands warm-up match against Uzbekistan, which the Dutch won 2–0 through two penalties converted by Gakpo. Malen, a current AS Roma player, failed to capitalize on the chance in the penalty area—an uncharacteristic error for him. This marked his second blank outing in the pre-World Cup friendlies, having also failed to score in an earlier test against Algeria, which ended in defeat. Netherlands coach Koeman addressed the finishing concerns in his post-match press conference, acknowledging the squad's broader issue with converting opportunities. The coach noted that in both recent friendlies, the team had scored only from penalties, adding pressure to performers in open play. Koeman stated: "In these two matches we've scored two goals from penalties. We create the chances, but if we don't score these matches we risk drawing them. Summerville and Malen missed two goals." The Netherlands opens its World Cup campaign on 14 June against Japan, followed by matches against Sweden and Tunisia. Malen's involvement in those fixtures will be closely watched given his recent form in front of goal during the preparatory phase.

More on Mile Svilar

Player profile →
Roma Reject Chelsea's €50M Bid for Svilar, Seek Financial Solutions Before June Deadline
Transfer NewsClub News AI
13h ago

Roma Reject Chelsea's €50M Bid for Svilar, Seek Financial Solutions Before June Deadline

Roma have turned down a €50 million offer from Chelsea for goalkeeper Mile Svilar as the club works to balance Financial Fair Play obligations. Head coach Gian Piero Gasperini prefers to retain his squad's key players, but Roma must generate €50 million in asset sales ('plusvalenze') by June 30th. The club is exploring sales of fringe players and loanees rather than parting with star names like Soulé, Manu Koné, or Evan N'Dicka. Recent deals include Lens purchasing Saud Abdülhamid for €3.5 million and Elche acquiring Buba Sangarè for €4.5 million. Other potential exits involve Tommaso Baldanzi, who may join Genoa permanently, and Marash Kumbulla, whose loan to Maiorca ended after the club's relegation. Nottingham Forest have expressed interest in defender Jan Ziolkowski, valued at €15 million following his €6.5 million purchase last summer. Roma are also reportedly in discussions with UEFA to secure an extended deadline to fulfill their settlement agreement, potentially pushing the requirement to 2027.

Cult of CalcioRead original →
Gasperini Shields Roma's Defence with Key Quartet Retained
Squad NewsClub News AI
2d ago

Gasperini Shields Roma's Defence with Key Quartet Retained

Head coach Gian Piero Gasperini has signalled to AS Roma's leadership that he wants to keep the club's defensive core intact for the coming season. The four pillars of the backline—goalkeeper Mile Svilar, defenders Gianluca Mancini, Ndicka, and Hermoso—are central to Gasperini's plans as he aims to build on Roma's recent stability. Svilar is regarded as an exceptional goalkeeper whom the club cannot afford to lose. Hermoso's annual renewal clause was exercised in May, while Mancini has been secured by Gasperini and awaits a contract extension with no doubts surrounding his future. Ndicka, the final member of the quartet, has been subject to months of speculation about a potential departure, but losing a centre-back of his quality does not appeal to Gasperini. Gasperini's emphasis on defensive continuity reflects the improvements made during his tenure. Roma's defence conceded only 31 goals in the recently concluded Serie A campaign, the second-best record in the division. After an initial period of adaptation, the coach established stability at the back. By retaining this defensive foundation, Gasperini intends to push Roma even higher in the league standings. The club faces the challenge of balancing Gasperini's clear wishes to maintain squad cohesion while managing various contract situations and transfer rumours affecting the group.

Svilar compares favorably with Europe's elite goalkeepers
AnalysisSquad News AI
6d ago

Svilar compares favorably with Europe's elite goalkeepers

Mile Svilar has established himself as a crucial figure for AS Roma, with statistics placing him among the continent's top goalkeepers. The analysis benchmarks his performance against leading European shot-stoppers, reflecting his rise as a reliable custodian for the Giallorossi. Svilar's numbers demonstrate his consistency and shot-stopping ability at the highest level, confirming Roma's confidence in him as a long-term solution in goal. His emergence as a genuine contender among Europe's best represents a significant asset for the club as they compete domestically and in continental competition.

More on Devyne Rensch

Player profile →
Greenwood deal grows complicated as Fenerbahce agreement emerges; Serie A 2026–27 fixture calendar announced
Transfer NewsSquad News AI
4d ago

Greenwood deal grows complicated as Fenerbahce agreement emerges; Serie A 2026–27 fixture calendar announced

Roma's pursuit of Mason Greenwood has hit a significant obstacle. Hakan Safi, a candidate for the Fenerbahce presidency, has moved directly to secure the English winger and announced an agreement for a four-year contract. Gasperini remains keen on Greenwood as a key target to strengthen the squad, but Roma must now navigate intense competition from the Turkish club to complete any deal. With the Greenwood situation unfolding, Roma's recruitment strategy has expanded to address other areas. Gasperini is conducting a wide search for a left-winger, with Summerville topping the wish list, though that acquisition would prove difficult. Alternative targets include Tzolis of Club Brugge, Igor Paixao of Marseille, Mathys Tel, and Mika Godts. Players including Nusa and Alajbegovic have been ruled out. On the right flank, Gasperini is seeking reinforcement, specifically a left-footed winger, with Wesley expected to remain on the left next season. Celik is viewed as a defensive back option despite potential contract renewal, while Rensch will serve as a backup. The transfer window remains active as Roma adjusts its targets amid external competition. The Serie A 2026–27 fixture calendar has also been released, with no major surprises for the club's scheduling.

Gasperini's final lineup decisions ahead of Verona clash: Ghilardi, Rensch, and Koné in focus
Match ReportSquad News AI
16d ago

Gasperini's final lineup decisions ahead of Verona clash: Ghilardi, Rensch, and Koné in focus

AS Roma face Hellas Verona in a crucial match where the Giallorossi control their own destiny in the race for Champions League qualification. Head coach Gian Piero Gasperini has settled on his attacking lineup, fielding the dream front three of Matías Soulé, Paulo Dybala, and Donyell Malen. The tactical setup aims to secure victory without relying on results elsewhere. Gasperini retains some flexibility in midfield, with the possibility of starting Koné from the outset as the coach seeks to settle the match early. In defence, former Roma player Ghilardi returns to the Bentegodi as a replacement for the absent Ndicka, marking his first appearance at his former home ground in a year. On the right flank, Rensch is expected to start ahead of Wesley, tasked with repeating an impressive performance from the Parma fixture. The squad selection reflects Gasperini's intent to field his strongest available players to maximize Roma's chances of claiming the three points needed to secure Champions League football. The formation is set as a 3-4-2-1, with Mile Svilar in goal and Gianluca Mancini anchoring the defensive line.

El Aynaoui set to start as Koné benched in Roma's crucial Verona clash
Match ReportSquad News AI
16d ago

El Aynaoui set to start as Koné benched in Roma's crucial Verona clash

Roma face Hellas Verona in a make-or-break match for Champions League qualification, with head coach Gasperini fielding a squad affected by several absences. Wesley is suspended, Ndicka is injured, and Koné—though fit—will start on the bench, with El Aynaoui taking his place in midfield. Rensch will replace the unavailable right-back, and Ghilardi features in defence. Up front, the Argentine pairing of Paulo Dybala and Matías Soulé will operate behind Donyell Malen. Three points at Verona would secure fourth place and Champions League football for Roma, an achievement the club has not reached in seven years. The fixture represents a pivotal moment for the team's immediate future. Multiple Italian newspapers—Gazzetta dello Sport, Il Messaggero, Corriere dello Sport, Corriere della Sera, and Il Tempo—have outlined near-identical expected lineups, with Mile Svilar in goal, a defensive line of Ghilardi, Gianluca Mancini, and Hermoso, and a midfield anchored by Bryan Cristante and El Aynaoui alongside full-backs Celik and Rensch. The consensus across Italian media reflects widespread agreement on Gasperini's tactical approach for this decisive encounter.

Feedback