Atalanta Test: Roma's First Major Challenge Under Gasperini

Santiago Castro entered Roma's match against Atalanta at the 62nd minute as an unlikely substitute, replacing the league's in-form forward Donyell Malen, yet the move proved to be the turning point in a game the hosts trailed. In his brief appearance, Castro struck the post and crossbar while providing two key passes, underscoring the quality of Roma's bench and prompting head coach Gian Piero Gasperini to praise his aggression. The Argentine's introduction illustrated the gulf between Roma's attacking depth now and the crisis that plagued them throughout the previous season. Last season Gasperini struggled with inadequate backup at centre-forward. Artem Dovbyk managed only 386 minutes in the league, while Evan Ferguson accumulated 776; injuries to both forced the coach into makeshift solutions, sometimes fielding a lone striker. Malen's January arrival from Dortmund transformed the dynamic, yet even then Gasperini was stretched thin managing the Dutchman's workload in a frenetic system that demands fresh energy. Castro's arrival this summer completes the picture. The forward combines goal-scoring instinct, the ability to run channels, ball retention and defensive work rate—qualities already evident in his early outings in red and gold. Gasperini's post-match verdict captured the shift: "The changes were good and that's what we were looking for—to complete this squad with substitutes who could give important help across matches. In finishing and in the forward area we were good, but we lacked intensity. We were sometimes too neat, aside from Castro's post and crossbar." Against Atalanta, Castro fired four shots—two on target and two off the woodwork—laying down a marker as a genuine alternative to Malen. Soulé scored, Molina offered fresh options on the flank and Balerdi commanded the defence like a squad veteran. Gasperini acknowledged the possibility of using both attackers together: "Castro and Malen together? It's an idea for the future. They can coexist, definitely. They can play together. We'll see; we're doing evaluations now. We'll have many matches so there will be chances for everyone and also to vary these systems." The contrast with previous seasons is stark. Roma's manager can now turn to a bench and find genuine competition for the starting eleven rather than, as José Mourinho once lamented, mere children. The scale of available rotation across the squad—particularly in attack and defence—represents a luxury rarely seen at Trigoria in recent years.

Roma will make their Champions League debut for seven years when they travel to Istanbul to face Fenerbahçe on 8 September, their first taste of Europe's premier competition since March 2019. After winning their opening three Serie A matches, Gian Piero Gasperini's side returns to the tournament that has been absent from the Stadio Olimpico since the 2018–19 season, when Roma last played in it away to Porto in the round of 16 under Eusebio Di Francesco. The gulf between then and now is vast: that side held De Rossi as captain and featured Dzeko, Kolarov, Marcano, Manolas, Juan Jesus and Karsdorp in defence. Today, Roma take the pitch with fresh momentum and a manager ready for his 35th Champions League bench. For Gasperini, Istanbul marks a return to the tournament after his Atalanta years. Across 34 previous Champions League matches as a coach, his record stands at 12 victories, 9 draws and 13 defeats. His sole previous campaign outside Atalanta came in 2011 on Inter's bench, when he lost 1–0 to Trabzonspor at San Siro. Atalanta provided all 33 other appearances, including his finest hour: the 2019–20 quarter-final against Paris Saint-Germain, a result that stings still. Atalanta had led 1–0 thanks to Pasalic until the 90th minute, before Marquinhos and Choupo-Moting scored at 90 and 93 minutes respectively. His last Champions League outing was the playoff elimination against Club Brugge in the 2024–25 season, a 5–2 aggregate defeat. For Fenerbahçe, the wait has been even longer: 18 years since they last featured in the group phase, which was the 2008–09 season. Roma's drought has lasted seven years, their previous fixture coming on 6 March 2019, a 3–1 loss after extra time to Porto. Across all European competitions, Roma have played 111 matches, recording 41 victories, 27 draws and 43 defeats, with their finest hour the 1984 European Cup final against Liverpool, decided on penalties. Fenerbahçe's best European run reached the quarter-finals in 2007–08, when they beat Chelsea 2–1 at home before elimination. The two clubs have never met in an official fixture; their only previous encounter was a friendly on 19 August 2014 at the Olimpico, which finished 3–3 before 35,000 spectators in Roma's pre-season presentation under Rudi Garcia. Totti opened the scoring from a penalty at 26 minutes; Bruno Alves equalised from a free-kick six minutes later. Kuyt and Sow put Fenerbahçe 3–1 up in the second half before Mattia Destro's double at 82 and 86 minutes secured a draw. Salih Uçan, who had transferred from Fenerbahçe to Roma weeks before, appeared for Roma in that second half. Romelu Lukaku, who spent one season at Roma as their centre-forward two years ago, will lead Fenerbahçe's attack. He scored 21 goals in 47 appearances for Roma—13 in Serie A, 7 in the Europa League and 1 in the Coppa Italia—under both Mourinho and De Rossi before joining Napoli. Mason Greenwood, the English forward who came close to signing for Roma this summer before Fenerbahçe's intervention secured his services with a substantial offer, will also feature. Mattéo Guendouzi, the French midfielder, is suspended for four match days by UEFA—two of them suspended for a year—following the incident in the playoff against Lyon, and will miss Roma's visit and the subsequent match against Aston Villa. Vedat Muriqi, the Kosovo striker who returned to Fenerbahçe after a spell at Mallorca, has already scored three goals in seven appearances this season, including the decisive strike in a 2–1 win over Lyon that sealed qualification. Jayden Oosterwolde, the defender, was due to join Roma after arriving at Ciampino on 25 August, but a medical examination revealed a serious issue with his left thigh beyond the initial diagnosis. After Roma attempted to renegotiate and Fenerbahçe refused, he returned to Istanbul and underwent surgery in Finland on 1 September; he will watch from the sidelines.

Roma's remarkable late comeback against Atalanta has impressed pundit Lele Adani, who analysed the performance on La Domenica Sportiva. Mario Hermoso equalised in the 89th minute before Roma scored again within three minutes, with Adani highlighting the intensity of the attack: Matías Soulé, Paulo Dybala and Santiago Castro all shot during that spell, firing once every 40 seconds in September heat at the Stadio Olimpico with the thermometer at 35 degrees. Adani drew parallels to Gasperini's Atalanta sides, describing Roma's display as an act of faith rather than conventional football. He was struck by Roma's persistence in creating chances even when the match appeared lost and the crowd's overwhelming support. The club completed 39 shots across the entire fixture, which Adani called epic football shaped by the team's determination to attack in the final minutes.

Roma return to the Champions League for the first time in seven years on Thursday 10 September, travelling to Istanbul to face Fenerbahce in the League Phase's first matchday with a 18:45 kickoff. The match will be broadcast on Sky Sport and available to subscribers via Sky Go. Gasperini's side arrive in buoyant form after a 2–1 comeback win against Atalanta in Serie A, where Hermoso and Soulé scored in the closing stages, and have won their opening three league matches. Roma are expected to line up in a 3–4–2–1 formation with Svilar in goal, a back three of Mancini, N'Dicka and Hermoso, Wesley and Molina as full-backs, Cristante and Koné in midfield, and Dybala and Soulé supporting lone striker Malen. Molina and N'Dicka remain in contention with alternatives, and the squad picture will become clearer in training over the coming days. Lorenzo Pellegrini is almost certain to remain absent. Fenerbahce will be without Guendouzi, the former Lazio midfielder, who is serving a four-match suspension (two of which are conditional) following a fight during their qualifier against Lyon. The Turkish side reached the League Phase unbeaten through the preliminaries, eliminating Górnik Zabrze, Sturm Graz and Lyon, though they suffered a recent domestic setback when losing the derby to Besiktas after wins over Konyaspor and Samsunspor. In European competition they remain unbeaten across seven matches. Their probable lineup shows Ederson in goal, Semedo, Škriniar, Aké and Brown across the defence, Kanté and Yüksek in midfield, and Asensio, Aktürkoğlu and Nene behind striker Lukaku. This will be the first official meeting between the two clubs. Fenerbahce have won their last three home matches against Serie A sides without conceding, the most recent a 2–0 victory over Lazio in the 2012–13 Europa League quarter-finals. Official team lineups will be announced approximately one hour before kickoff, around 17:45 Italian time.

Roma secured a 2–1 home victory over Atalanta on 5 September 2026, their first win at the Olimpico against the Bergamo side since 5 March 2022. After falling behind through Ederson's goal in the second half, Roma fought back without capitulating as they had in previous seasons. Mario Hermoso equalised with a header from a corner on the left wing, meeting the ball with a delicate chip. Matías Soulé then settled the match at the 93rd minute, cutting inside with his right foot before crossing with his left to find the far post and beat Carnesecchi. The performance at Trigoria on the morning after the match drew praise, with staff noting the return to form of Soulé. Gasperini's side demonstrated growing resilience as the season progresses, refusing to surrender despite going behind. The comeback underlined a shift in mentality compared to the previous campaign. Hermoso's involvement from set-piece defence and Soulé's match-winning intervention were highlights of Roma's recovery, with the latter's impact immediately evident upon his introduction. Press ratings reflected the quality on display. Hermoso earned marks ranging from 6.5 to 7.5 across outlets, with one publication rating him 7.5 for his performance. Soulé, brought on in the 54th minute, received ratings between 7.5 and 8.5. Paulo Dybala was marked between 6 and 8, while Bryan Cristante and Manu Koné drew ratings of 5.5 to 7.5 and 6.5 to 7.5 respectively. Manager Gasperini received ratings between 7 and 8 from the newspapers assessed.

Roma delivered a dramatic comeback at the start of matchday three to beat Atalanta, with Matías Soulé scoring at the 93rd minute to seal the three points. The Argentine forward, who also provided an assist, was the standout performer in what the Italian press dubbed a statement win for the Giallorossi this season. Mario Hermoso proved instrumental in reigniting the match when it appeared lost, while head coach Gian Piero Gasperini earned widespread praise for his tactical management. The victory is being framed as Roma's first authentic championship display of the campaign, with the comeback signalling a bold statement to the league's other top clubs. Soulé's performance drew particular attention from Italy's major sports newspapers, with the 54th-minute substitute recapturing the form that impressed observers last season. Hermoso's contribution, meanwhile, was credited with turning the tide when the match seemed to be slipping away. Across ratings from Corriere dello Sport, Gazzetta dello Sport, Il Messaggero, Corriere della Sera, La Repubblica, and Il Tempo, Soulé received the highest individual marks, with Corriere dello Sport awarding him 8.5 out of 10 for his performance off the bench. Hermoso's ratings ranged from 6.5 to 7.5, while Gasperini received marks between 7 and 8 across the publications. Bryan Cristante and Manu Koné were also highlighted for their midfield contributions, with Cristante earning 7.5 from Corriere dello Sport. Paulo Dybala received marks ranging from 6 to 8. The match formation was recorded as 3-4-1-2, with substitutions bringing on Daniele Ghilardi, Leonardo Balerdi, Nahuel Molina, and Santiago Castro during the course of play.

Daniele Ghilardi has emerged as one of the season's surprises at Roma. After months of adaptation last season following his arrival from Verona, the defender earned Gasperini's trust, yet began the campaign without a league start across the opening eighteen matches. His turning point came at Lecce, where he suddenly stepped into the side and performed flawlessly. Last week at the same venue he was named in the starting eleven again, producing four tackles won from five attempts, eight ground duels won and aerial supremacy. On Saturday against Atalanta, Ghilardi replaced Gianluca Mancini and contributed significantly to Roma's comeback. Gasperini chose to release Jan Ziółkowski over the summer in favour of keeping the 2003-born defender, continuing a pattern of player development that has become a hallmark of his management at Roma. Crucially, Italy national team coach Roberto Mancini attended the Olimpico fixture and took note of the performance. While Ghilardi remains too early for September's international break, Mancini is expected to consider him for future call-ups.

Roma commentators have praised the team's attacking display and tactical discipline following a win over Atalanta, with radio panelists highlighting Matías Soulé's performance and head coach Gian Piero Gasperini's growing imprint on the squad. Mirabella told Radio Romanista that Soulé was the standout performer, noting his immediate impact despite uncertainty over his future. "Today Matías Soulé felt at home," he said. Frequelli credited Mario Hermoso as the best player on the pitch, citing both his contribution to Roma's equaliser and his resilience after contributing to Atalanta's goal. Bighi echoed the praise for Soulé's growth and drew attention to Gasperini's tactical approach: "The manager is working very well. The squad has won not just through passion but through the work Gasperini is doing." Carina told Radio Radio that Roma has finally become "Gasperiniana"—reflecting the same style viewers saw in Gasperini's Atalanta teams. He noted an unusual tactical choice in the match, saying Gasperini won the game by removing two defenders: "If he hadn't taken off N'Dicka and Mancini, Roma would have suffered the second goal, because both struggle against Kristovic and go into difficulty. With Ghilardi and Balerdi, Roma regains the centre." He identified Rodrigo Mora as a player capable of beating defenders one-on-one but requiring development, while flagging the underlying financial burden: "The problem Roma carries with it is the cost: 50 million." Orsi credited Roma's fitness and tactical organisation, noting they have scored 10 goals across their first three matches this season. "Roma merits more than the 9 points in the league table," he said. Pruzzo expressed reservations about Mora, stating: "In a half he doesn't touch ten passes, though on a couple of occasions he did well. If he doesn't improve in level, I have the impression that something else is needed." Di Giovambattista highlighted Paulo Dybala's contribution of four assists in three games and praised the crowd's role in Roma's comeback. Pes told TeleradioStereo that Gasperini's next step must be restoring Dybala's goal-scoring form, adding: "Roma have conviction and hunger. Winning in Istanbul allows you to start a good path. It's a tough stadium to face, but Roma feel they can win the match."

Gasperini's tactical gamble paid off as Roma came from behind to beat Atalanta, with five substitutions made by the 21st minute of the second half transforming a match the club was losing 1–0 after Ederson's goal. With Ndicka and Mancini struggling against Atalanta's counter-attacks, Gasperini brought on Molina, Soulé, Castro, Ghilardi and Balerdi in rapid succession. The changes proved decisive: Ghilardi and Balerdi immediately steadied the defence and neutralised Atalanta's transitions, while Castro came close with efforts that hit the post and crossbar. Soulé delivered the most telling contribution, providing an assist and scoring a goal in the 93rd minute—an impact matching what he produced in Roma's match at Lecce. Gasperini had stated before the match: "Titolari and riserve ormai non contano più, si gioca in sedici"—effectively that first-team status and substitutes no longer matter, the game is played by sixteen—and the field immediately vindicated him. The depth demonstrated reflects substantial improvement from the previous season. In a match such as Parma last May, the bench contained only Venturino and Vaz; Gasperini now has access to a squad rich with genuine alternatives capable of reshaping a match. The quality of those replacements gives him the tactical weapons to win even when games turn against Roma mid-contest.

Atalanta sporting director Cristiano Giuntoli confirmed that Marten de Roon requested a move to Roma during the transfer window that has just closed. Speaking at a press conference to present Frank Kessié, Giuntoli said: "When a player asks to leave, you have to listen to him. He asked us to go to Roma and we threw ourselves at Kessié." De Roon joined Roma's squad this summer after spending the previous season with Atalanta. Giuntoli explained Atalanta's approach to the midfielder's departure: "We're sorry, but we have to turn the page and move forward. Kessié is a player with personality who can help us in this new Atalanta." The signing of Kessié was presented as the club's solution to replacing the departing midfielder.

A confrontation between Atalanta CEO Luca Percassi and Roma sporting director Tony D'Amico at the Olimpico on Saturday evening has escalated into a formal dispute. According to reports published today by Il Romanista, Corriere dello Sport and la Repubblica, Percassi followed D'Amico as both clubs were leaving the stadium, pursuing him towards the Monte Mario car park. The Atalanta executive directed heavy language at D'Amico, with Corriere dello Sport reporting insults that questioned both professional and personal qualities. D'Amico did not respond in kind and attempted to leave, but Percassi continued the verbal assault all the way to the car park, reportedly accompanied by his wife. The confrontation escalated to the point where stadium stewards and security had to intervene to prevent further escalation. The clash reflects deteriorated relations dating back months. D'Amico spent four seasons at Atalanta before joining Roma, but his departure was far less cordial than officially presented. He had pushed to move to Roma while Atalanta had already identified Cristiano Giuntoli for the sporting director role; D'Amico remained blocked for weeks before his release, hampering Roma's early transfer work. The tension has only deepened given overlapping personnel moves: head coach Gian Piero Gasperini departed Atalanta for Roma, followed by D'Amico, and now midfielder Marten de Roon has joined Roma. Corriere dello Sport reports a significant detail: Gasperini himself telephoned Percassi directly to facilitate de Roon's transfer to Roma—a notable contact given Gasperini had experienced disagreements with the Atalanta executive, though maintained a relationship with his father Antonio. Roma has called Percassi's conduct "unacceptable," while Atalanta has firmly rejected the Roma version of events. The matter now passes to the Federal Prosecutor's office. Prosecutor Giuseppe Chiné will evaluate available evidence and interview those directly involved and witnesses, including the intervening stewards. The case has moved beyond internal stadium corridors into formal sporting justice proceedings.

Roma have a numerically shorter squad than last season yet paradoxically possess far more possibilities, a pattern evident across the opening three matches and most starkly demonstrated by the victory against Atalanta. Ten players departed from the squad that closed last season while six arrived: Koulierakis, Balerdi, Mora, Castro, Molina and De Roon. The club has contracted in size but fundamentally shifted the quality of its alternatives. Against Atalanta, Castro struck twice against the woodwork, Soulé provided an assist and the decisive goal, Balerdi made an immediate impact on his debut, while Ghilardi and Molina helped reshape the team during its most difficult moments. This underlines a crucial difference from a year ago. Head coach Gasperini anticipated the pattern before the match, stating: "Starters and substitutes no longer matter; you play with 16 players." With the Champions League approaching, this depth becomes potentially decisive—rotations will be inevitable and Roma must sustain their level even with changed personnel. The squad remains tight and will probably require reinforcement in January, but one fact is already clear: Roma have narrowed numerically but expanded in quality.