← All stories
Roma's defensive problems go beyond Svilar's absence
·5 November 2026·2h ago

Roma's defensive problems go beyond Svilar's absence

Source: Forza Roma

Roma's defensive troubles cannot be blamed solely on the absence of goalkeeper Mile Svilar, though the Belgian's impact was clear when he was fit and his absence has been felt since he was sidelined by a finger injury. Before Svilar stepped aside, Roma had conceded four goals: one against Atalanta (Krstovic), one against Fenerbahce (Brown) and two against Inter (a brace from Lautaro). Since then, Roma have shown problems at the back, despite the far from ordinary performances of Gollini.

The real imbalance has come in the Champions League, where Roma have conceded eight and scored ten. In Serie A they have conceded 28 and scored 10. The problem Roma continue to struggle with is most evident against the strongest and most prestigious opponents. Gasperini believes the cause is probably a lack of concentration, linked to a missing mentality. The side often gives up control of matches at the first difficulty, a trend present since the start of the season in both league and cup. Roma have suffered comebacks and goals conceded shortly after half-time, and the side has been unable to change the rhythm of games when things go wrong. The group loses its bearings at the first setback and, knowing only one way to play, struggles to create a different tempo or new momentum, Como aside.

Finally, the article points to a problem that investment can solve. Roma's squad is very good for the league, but not yet for the demanding double commitment of playing in both Serie A and the Champions League.

● AI Generated Summary

This summary was generated by an AI model. Always read the source for complete and accurate information.

Story Coverage2 sources on this story

Roma's strong form in Serie A has not carried over to the Champions League, where the club continues to lose ground in the biggest European matches. Il Messaggero and Forza Roma both point to the absence of first-choice goalkeeper Mile Svilar, who has been sidelined by injury, as a major factor. Il Messaggero describes the injury generally, while Forza Roma specifies a finger injury. Both outlets credit Gollini for his efforts in goal and note the emergency debut of Devis Vásquez at Old Trafford, but say the team has missed Svilar's presence in decisive moments.

The outlets differ on the numbers. Il Messaggero reports that Roma have conceded 10 goals and scored 28 in Serie A, while in seven continental matches they have scored 8 and conceded 10. Forza Roma gives the reverse Serie A figures, with 28 conceded and 10 scored, and says Roma have conceded eight and scored ten in the Champions League. Il Messaggero also counts 14 goals conceded in the last seven official games in all competitions. Forza Roma notes that Roma conceded four goals before Svilar's absence, including Krstovic for Atalanta, Brown for Fenerbahce, and a brace from Lautaro for Inter.

Forza Roma argues that the problem goes beyond the goalkeeper and is rooted in mentality. Gasperini reportedly believes a lack of concentration is to blame, as the side often loses control at the first setback and struggles to change the tempo, with Como as the exception. Il Messaggero links the issue to rotation and pressure, and both outlets argue the squad needs strengthening. Il Messaggero points to the January transfer window as an opportunity to add experienced players, while Forza Roma says investment is needed for the demands of playing in both Serie A and the Champions League.

AI synthesis of all sources below — always check the originals.

Testo Originale / Source Text

“Ma possibile che tutto il problema sia riconducibile, solo, all'assenza di Mile Svilar? Possibile, ma non è proprio tutto. Diciamo che il portierone belga ha inciso quando c'era e ha deciso quando è mancato: è il destino dei grandi personaggi, che si notano sia quando sono presenti ma di più quando…”

Read the full article in Italian at Forza Roma.

Read original on Forza Roma →

More Analysis

Roma take stock after Old Trafford as Gasperini's thin squad comes under scrutiny
AnalysisSquad News● AI
2h ago

Roma take stock after Old Trafford as Gasperini's thin squad comes under scrutiny

Roma are reflecting on a narrow defeat at Manchester United's Old Trafford, with Corriere della Sera highlighting both the individual progress within Gian Piero Gasperini's squad and the structural limits of a group that must compete on three fronts. Those limits, the report says, will require corrections in the January transfer window. Matías Soulé, now a key technical reference on the right side of the attack, is among the bright spots, along with the impact of Malen, who has produced important numbers in the giallorossi shirt, and the consistent form of Ndicka. However, a thin squad and an injury crisis have restricted Gasperini's rotations and exposed the gap with the top sides on Europe's biggest stages. The difficulties against the Red Devils were made worse by heavy absences in goal and in midfield. The club's management and Tony D'Amico, who is already working to identify the profiles needed in January, are reportedly targeting a midfielder and a left-sided winger to give Gasperini the alternatives he has asked for. The squad has returned to Trigoria to prepare for the Serie A clash with Sassuolo. The medical staff are monitoring Manu Koné, who is aiming for a rapid recovery, while the goalkeeping situation centres on Gollini, who is dealing with a back problem, with Colombian Devis Vásquez ready to step in again.

Roma's nine-game, 27-day stress test nears its end at the Olimpico
AnalysisEurope● AI
2h ago

Roma's nine-game, 27-day stress test nears its end at the Olimpico

Roma's run of nine matches in 27 days ends at the Stadio Olimpico the day after next, bringing a demanding spell that has tested the squad on three fronts. The sequence began with Como and Sassuolo, with Champions League fixtures in between, and the last of them is the trip to Manchester United, who could overturn Roma's initial two-goal advantage. The working assumption, noted since late August, is that Roma have improved on last season's third-place finish. Simone Valdarchi, writing in Il Tempo, credits the greater understanding between coach and squad, with the club's transfer business also playing a part. A second, fairly obvious view is that the squad is short in depth. Even if it is not inadequate, it is thin enough to be stretched across three competitions. That is the stress test, and some players have passed it. Soulé's form over this period has stood out, and he has become a key technical reference in the trequarti. Still, the article argues that the team needs something more to keep progressing. D'Amico knows this well.

Roma's defence under the spotlight as Svilar's absence weighs on Champions League campaign
EuropeAnalysis● AI
2h ago

Roma's defence under the spotlight as Svilar's absence weighs on Champions League campaign

Roma's excellent run of results and defensive balance in Serie A has not carried over to the Champions League, where the club continues to suffer lapses in the big European fixtures, according to Il Messaggero. Gian Piero Gasperini's side have conceded 10 goals in Serie A while scoring 28, but in their seven continental matches, including the qualifiers and group stage, they have scored just 8 and conceded 10. The negative trend is compounded by 14 goals conceded across their last seven official games in all competitions. A key factor identified in the analysis is the enforced absence of Mile Svilar in goal. The Belgian keeper's injury has deprived the team of a charismatic figure and a fundamental reference point for the Giallorossi backline. Despite the efforts of Gollini beforehand, and the recent emergency debut of Devis Vásquez at Old Trafford, the absence of the first-choice keeper continues to be felt in decisive moments. The analysis also points to rotation and mentality under maximum pressure. Difficulties in managing a two-goal lead or in facing late comebacks by opponents reflect, the piece argues, the need to strengthen the squad available to Gasperini. The January transfer window could offer the chance to add experienced players capable of bringing weight and balance to support the club's European ambitions.

More on Mile Svilar

Player profile →
Gasperini back to full strength as Roma's fixture list eases during the international break
Squad NewsSerie A● AI
1h ago

Gasperini back to full strength as Roma's fixture list eases during the international break

Roma head into the international break with their whole squad available to Gian Piero Gasperini, and the fixture list is now working in their favour. The club have played nine matches in 27 days, and a run of more winnable games is set to follow. This Saturday Sassuolo visit the Stadio Olimpico, a side in serious crisis with coach Aquilani reportedly at risk of being dismissed despite a strong start to the season. The break comes at a crucial moment for Roma, allowing Gasperini to gradually bring back all of his injured players. Manu Koné and Paulo Dybala both hope to be available in two days' time, but after a month out both will certainly be ready for the trip to Parma. Mile Svilar returns in goal at the Tardini. Devyne Rensch, who is dealing with an adductor strain, undergoes instrumental tests today and has two weeks to return to full availability. The next league fixtures for Malen and his team are, on paper at least, easier: Sassuolo, Parma, Monza and Bologna in a row. That gives Roma the chance to build a winning run before the derby against Lazio. In between come the daunting trip to Paris and the Champions League clash with Sporting CP.

Roma's defence under the spotlight as Svilar's absence weighs on Champions League campaign
EuropeAnalysis● AI
2h ago

Roma's defence under the spotlight as Svilar's absence weighs on Champions League campaign

Roma's excellent run of results and defensive balance in Serie A has not carried over to the Champions League, where the club continues to suffer lapses in the big European fixtures, according to Il Messaggero. Gian Piero Gasperini's side have conceded 10 goals in Serie A while scoring 28, but in their seven continental matches, including the qualifiers and group stage, they have scored just 8 and conceded 10. The negative trend is compounded by 14 goals conceded across their last seven official games in all competitions. A key factor identified in the analysis is the enforced absence of Mile Svilar in goal. The Belgian keeper's injury has deprived the team of a charismatic figure and a fundamental reference point for the Giallorossi backline. Despite the efforts of Gollini beforehand, and the recent emergency debut of Devis Vásquez at Old Trafford, the absence of the first-choice keeper continues to be felt in decisive moments. The analysis also points to rotation and mentality under maximum pressure. Difficulties in managing a two-goal lead or in facing late comebacks by opponents reflect, the piece argues, the need to strengthen the squad available to Gasperini. The January transfer window could offer the chance to add experienced players capable of bringing weight and balance to support the club's European ambitions.

Fatigue, injuries and a thin squad make Gasperini's task an obstacle course
InjurySquad News● AI
3h ago

Fatigue, injuries and a thin squad make Gasperini's task an obstacle course

Roma's head coach Gian Piero Gasperini faces a growing problem as fatigue, injuries and a squad with limited numbers strain the club's challenge on two fronts: Serie A, where Roma are dreaming of the Scudetto, and the Champions League, where they want to make progress. The problem is that so many players are injured at once, and as the matches pile up and the season accelerates, the physical and mental demands become harder to meet. According to Alessandro Angeloni writing in Il Messaggero, Gasperini has had to deal with a series of significant absences this season. Losing Koné and Dybala in the same period has made things difficult. Covering absences at the back is easier, and while Svilar is missing, the coach has a group of reliable defenders behind him. The midfield is a different proposition: the solutions available are effective, but they depend on the form of those who are fit, and if de Roon begins to pay the price for the workload, it becomes a serious problem. The attack is the most critical area. As is well known, Roma lack a winger with very specific characteristics. Sporting director D'Amico himself has described this as the gap that should be filled in January. Roma need another player who can replace Dybala or Soulé up front, with Endrick cited as an example. Gasperini would like two more forwards in that area to feel comfortable.

More on Pierluigi Gollini

Player profile →
Roma take stock after Old Trafford as Gasperini's thin squad comes under scrutiny
AnalysisSquad News● AI
2h ago

Roma take stock after Old Trafford as Gasperini's thin squad comes under scrutiny

Roma are reflecting on a narrow defeat at Manchester United's Old Trafford, with Corriere della Sera highlighting both the individual progress within Gian Piero Gasperini's squad and the structural limits of a group that must compete on three fronts. Those limits, the report says, will require corrections in the January transfer window. Matías Soulé, now a key technical reference on the right side of the attack, is among the bright spots, along with the impact of Malen, who has produced important numbers in the giallorossi shirt, and the consistent form of Ndicka. However, a thin squad and an injury crisis have restricted Gasperini's rotations and exposed the gap with the top sides on Europe's biggest stages. The difficulties against the Red Devils were made worse by heavy absences in goal and in midfield. The club's management and Tony D'Amico, who is already working to identify the profiles needed in January, are reportedly targeting a midfielder and a left-sided winger to give Gasperini the alternatives he has asked for. The squad has returned to Trigoria to prepare for the Serie A clash with Sassuolo. The medical staff are monitoring Manu Koné, who is aiming for a rapid recovery, while the goalkeeping situation centres on Gollini, who is dealing with a back problem, with Colombian Devis Vásquez ready to step in again.

Roma's defence under the spotlight as Svilar's absence weighs on Champions League campaign
EuropeAnalysis● AI
2h ago

Roma's defence under the spotlight as Svilar's absence weighs on Champions League campaign

Roma's excellent run of results and defensive balance in Serie A has not carried over to the Champions League, where the club continues to suffer lapses in the big European fixtures, according to Il Messaggero. Gian Piero Gasperini's side have conceded 10 goals in Serie A while scoring 28, but in their seven continental matches, including the qualifiers and group stage, they have scored just 8 and conceded 10. The negative trend is compounded by 14 goals conceded across their last seven official games in all competitions. A key factor identified in the analysis is the enforced absence of Mile Svilar in goal. The Belgian keeper's injury has deprived the team of a charismatic figure and a fundamental reference point for the Giallorossi backline. Despite the efforts of Gollini beforehand, and the recent emergency debut of Devis Vásquez at Old Trafford, the absence of the first-choice keeper continues to be felt in decisive moments. The analysis also points to rotation and mentality under maximum pressure. Difficulties in managing a two-goal lead or in facing late comebacks by opponents reflect, the piece argues, the need to strengthen the squad available to Gasperini. The January transfer window could offer the chance to add experienced players capable of bringing weight and balance to support the club's European ambitions.

Koné pushing for Sassuolo return as Gasperini weighs injury doubts in goal and at right-back
InjurySquad News● AI
2h ago

Koné pushing for Sassuolo return as Gasperini weighs injury doubts in goal and at right-back

Roma returned to Trigoria on Wednesday evening after their Champions League trip to Manchester United and began preparing immediately for the Serie A match against Sassuolo, with little time to regroup. Head coach Gian Piero Gasperini is hoping to recover several key players from the treatment room. Manu Koné is progressing well towards full recovery and is aiming to be in contention for a place in the side against the neroverdi. Paulo Dybala has been back training on the pitch for a few days, but the medical staff's caution means he is unlikely to risk excessive effort, making a return to the matchday squad after the international break more likely. In goal, the situation is being monitored closely after recent physical problems. Gasperini returned from England still doubtful over Pierluigi Gollini, who is struggling with back discomfort that will be assessed day by day up to the eve of the match. If Gollini is ruled out, Colombian Devis Vásquez, who started at Old Trafford, is ready to keep his place between the posts for the league fixture as well. Devyne Rensch has also joined the injury list, suffering a muscle strain in his right adductor, and will undergo instrumental tests to determine his recovery time precisely. Gasperini and his staff are weighing up alternatives to reshape the team for the home match against Sassuolo. The Italian report confirms that the Roma squad's fitness updates will continue to be assessed through the coming days, with the coach balancing the returns of Koné and Dybala against the continued uncertainty at goalkeeper and right-back.

Feedback