Alessandro Romano's sale to Cagliari has become a flashpoint for criticism of Gasperini's transfer strategy, but the narrative conflates a promising young midfielder with an elite prospect and misreads Roma's reasoning for the deal.
Romano earned excessive hype after four strong matches with Cagliari, leading to comparisons with Rodri and a call-up to the Italy squad after just 451 minutes in Serie A. His debut for the national team proved disastrous and drew unwarranted criticism. The sale itself became weaponised against Roma—a club top of the league with unprecedented numbers—as though offloading Romano represented a catastrophic error. Roberto Mancini, Italy's current manager, fuelled the narrative, saying in a press conference: "Romano, I knew little of him, but he impressed me at the first matchday and I wanted to see him. I believe he can be important for the national team's future, he plays with first touch and Ranieri did well to flag him." Mancini's comments overlooked a key fact: Romano had debuted under Gasperini, who therefore did not rate him as poorly as the mythology suggests.
Gasperini's decision to sell Romano for a fee reaching €9 million with bonuses and a resale percentage was nearly unavoidable given squad structure and midfield depth. Romano would have been a fifth-choice option and lacked the characteristics ideal for Gasperini's system. The absence of a buyback clause is a legitimate point of debate, though including one would have significantly reduced the final figure. Within days, fears took hold that Roma had lost another De Rossi. Instead, the rush to portray Gasperini as foolish took precedence over assessing the emotional state of a young player who, a year earlier, was playing in Primavera.
The article suggests other young defenders—Ghilardi, Tresoldi, Kayode, and Pisilli (on loan to the Under-21s)—merit national team opportunities more than Romano, and that diplomatic victory over Switzerland mattered more to the discourse than sporting judgment.
Story Coverage2 sources on this story
Alessandro Romano's debut for Italy against Belgium on 26 September 2026 has reignited debate over Roma's decision to sell the midfielder to Cagliari. The Corriere della Sera sharply criticized Romano's performance in Italy's 2–0 defeat, focusing on his loss of possession in midfield that led directly to Belgium's opening goal through Godts. The newspaper was blunt in its assessment: "This Romano is not the new Rodri. Get that out of your head." Corriere della Sera used this to vindicate Gian Piero Gasperini's decision to let him leave, arguing that because Gasperini watched Romano daily at Trigoria and approved his loan to Spezia and subsequent permanent move to Cagliari, the coach must have identified something others are only now discovering.
Forza Roma, however, argues the narrative has weaponized Romano's sale unfairly against Roma. The outlet notes that Romano earned "excessive hype" after just four strong matches with Cagliari and 451 minutes in Serie A before earning his Italy call-up. It defends Gasperini's decision to sell for a fee reaching €9 million with bonuses and a resale percentage, arguing Romano would have been a fifth-choice midfielder lacking the characteristics ideal for Gasperini's system. Roberto Mancini's post-match comments praising Romano and suggesting he flagged the player to Roma added fuel to the debate, though Forza Roma contends this overlooks that Romano had debuted under Gasperini in the first place. Both outlets agree that a single poor performance cannot define a 20-year-old's career, yet the contrasting takes reflect deeper disagreement about whether Roma lost emerging talent or made prudent business sense.
AI synthesis of all sources below — always check the originals.
Testo Originale / Source Text
“Ne abbiamo lette tante, sentite ancora di più. Alessandro Romano dopo quattro buone partite col Cagliari era automaticamente diventato il nuovo Rodri. A furor di popolo, ormai popolino. Perché il ragazzo di sicuro promette bene ed è un buon centrocampista, ma niente di più. Almeno per ora. Invece…”
Read the full article in Italian at Forza Roma.