Roma show vulnerabilities in European debut as defensive flaws emerge

Roma travel to Turin on Monday at 18:30 for the fourth Serie A match of the season aiming to secure a fourth consecutive league victory and maintain their position at the top of the table. The fixture will feature a compelling duel on the flanks between two rising stars of Italian football: Alessio Cacciamani of Torino and Emanuele Lulli of Roma, both born in 2007 and tipped as future resources for the Italian national team. Cacciamani was long pursued by Roma during the summer before joining Torino. He is a left-sided full-back capable of playing as either a traditional defender or an attacking winger, quick and technical, particularly effective when receiving the ball wide and taking on opponents. His game centres on accelerations, ball-carrying and attacking space, combining ball-playing quality with a willingness to join the attack. Though young, he already displays personality in one-on-one duels and a strong commitment to defensive work. In the first three league matches he has made 3 appearances, totalling 227 minutes and recording 1 assist. Lulli, a Roma academy graduate, has been a major surprise for head coach Gian Piero Gasperini this season. Gasperini handed him a starting role from the opening day against Fiorentina following a pre-season in which the young defender showed quality and character. Unlike Cacciamani, Lulli appears more structurally complete and balanced across both phases of play. He can operate as a right-sided defender but possesses the characteristics of a modern wing-back: good athleticism, defensive awareness, the ability to support attacking moves and notably solid quality in the final pass. He has started all three opening matches, accumulating 234 minutes, 4 key passes and 15 balls recovered, figures that underline his contribution in both build-up and defensive work. The flank contest promises to be particularly interesting: Cacciamani relies more on acceleration and one-on-one play, while Lulli can offer greater equilibrium and defensive reading. Both 2007-born players are already carrying significant responsibility at the highest level despite their youth, yet with distinctly different qualities.

Roma drew their first match of the season, a result that has handed fuel to the club's most vocal critics. A goal by Brown was enough to stir the naysayers from silence after Roma's bright start to the campaign. The criticism ranges widely: that Roma have faced no genuine test in the league; that Malen has misfired; that Mora is merely a former Porto substitute out of his depth; that Gasperini has grown quiet where he once railed against "Ricky"; that Mancini is finished; that Wesley's focus lies elsewhere; that Koné avoids celebrating goals with teammates for unexplained reasons; that Gasperini's substitutions were wrong; that when he withdrew Malen he brought on De Roon out of friendship rather than judgment, a claim absurd coming from those who called Castro an inexplicable signing in the first place; and that Rensch played only as a favour, a serious tactical error. The draw in Istanbul itself has become a flashpoint for those determined to cast shadows over both Roma and their manager. Critics claim it proves Roma have not faced quality opposition in domestic play. The broader narrative from the pessimists is one of decline and poor judgment—both in the squad assembled and in how it is being used. Yet the tone of the piece suggests the critics are opportunistic, seizing on a single result to resurrect doubts that the strong start had quieted. The article offers no quarter to this chorus of doom, treating their complaints with contempt as a predictable cycle: the naysayers announced player exits before 30 June; they questioned the signings of Castro and Balerdi; and now, having seen their early predictions of collapse proven wrong by the opening fixtures, they are back in full voice. The sense is one of inevitable, tiresome repetition—the "Brancaleone Army" undeterred and unrelenting in its determination to find failure.

Roma have scored ten goals and conceded just one in their opening matches of the 2026-27 season, establishing themselves as one of Europe's most potent attacking forces. The Giallorossi drew with Fenerbahce in their Champions League debut, a match in which Dybala and his teammates performed creditably in a hostile atmosphere. Gasperini now prepares Roma for Monday's fixture against Torino, expecting the same intensity shown in the early league games. The underlying statistics are remarkable: across three matches, Roma have recorded 71 shots while allowing only 22, a +49 differential that ranks second in Europe's five major leagues. Only Barcelona surpass them with a +58 difference. Barcelona also lead Roma on goals scored, 12 to 10, but the squads are incomparable—a gap illustrated when Barcelona defeated Feyenoord 5-1 in their own Champions League opener. Gasperini is pursuing a fourth consecutive victory, a streak Roma have not achieved since 2014.